The campaign clearly explains the heritage harm and the narrow lane issues, which is helpful for understanding the opposition. However, I wonder if the financial implications for the college or the city have been considered in these arguments?
Questions about Christ’s Lane Action Group
What is Christ’s Lane Action Group?
Christ’s Lane Action Group is a coalition of approximately 300 Cambridge residents and stakeholders dedicated to safeguarding the heritage, culture, and public amenity of Christ's Lane and the city's historic core. The group opposes a proposed extension to Christ's College Library and is organizing a petition and a judicial review of the original planning permission (case AC-2025-LON-004656). They also encourage the public to object to a subsequent planning application (reference 26/02109/FUL). The organization presents campaign arguments regarding heritage harm, daylight and sunlight impacts, and alternative proposals on their website.
What was the outcome of the judicial review against Cambridge City Council?
The group's judicial review, R (Christ's Lane Action Group) v Cambridge City Council, was granted permission to proceed on all four grounds by Mr Justice Kimblin in March 2026. On Tuesday 20 October 2026, the High Court quashed the Council’s first permission (25/02161/FUL) on all four grounds of the claim. The judge recorded 'errors of approach on each of the grounds', finding that the Council got it wrong on every ground regarding the planning permission for the library scheme.
What are the specific physical characteristics of the proposed library building?
The proposed building rises to over 14 metres along a lane only 6 metres wide, presenting a largely blank, fortress-like wall to the public. The new scheme also includes tall ventilation chimneys projecting from the Christ's Lane frontage. This development is situated within the Central Historic Core Conservation Area, adjacent to multiple Grade I listed buildings including the Bodley Library, First Court, and Bath Court.
What errors did the High Court identify in the Council's handling of the planning permission?
The Council misled councillors about Historic England’s advice by leaving out its finding of harm. Historic England found the building 'too big for its location' and 'overdominant on this space', with harm to the College’s own Grade I listed buildings. The Council also gave councillors confused and contradictory advice on the harm to a Grade I listed library, claiming the scheme would secure the 'optimum viable use' of the listed buildings when they were already in use.
How did the Council respond to the judicial review proceedings?
Thirteen days before the hearing, the same Council approved the identical scheme again on a report that repeats its errors and introduces new errors. The report stated there was 'no good reason' to wait for the Court. The Council asked the Court to look at that report, and the Court declined, noting there is no confidence that local planning processes are fit to decide this complex and controversial case in a rigorous, fair and lawful way.
What is the stance of Christ's College regarding the judicial review?
The Master of Christ’s College stated that 'the fact that a small group of residents does not like the outcome does not invalidate it'. However, the High Court quashed the approval on all four grounds, finding the scheme in conflict with the Council’s own heritage policy. The group argues that the Council's officers recommended approval anyway despite these conflicts.
Why is Christ's Lane significant to the local community and heritage?
Christ's Lane is one of Cambridge's busiest pedestrian routes, used by thousands of people every day. It provides a critical link between Christ's Pieces, the Drummer Street bus station, the historic city core, and the main shopping areas including Lion Yard and Grand Arcade. The Lane has existed in various forms since the 13th century, predating the founding of Christ's College in 1505.
What is the official website of Christ’s Lane Action Group?
The official website of Christ’s Lane Action Group is christslaneactiongroup.org.
How is Christ’s Lane Action Group rated on Trustburn?
On Trustburn, Christ’s Lane Action Group has a rating of 4 out of 5 based on 4 reviews.
AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.
The website clearly outlines the specific heritage concerns regarding the library’s massing and height relative to the Bodley Library, making the argument easy to follow.
What an incredibly vibrant and engaging platform for civic engagement! It is truly thrilling to see how Christ’s Lane Action Group has mobilized so many people around the future of our historic streets. The way they have laid out the case for the judicial review is both passionate and well-structured. I am particularly excited about the clear explanation of why the proposed library design might harm the Bodley Library’s setting. The fact that major heritage bodies agree there is heritage harm adds such weight to their arguments. It is fantastic that they provide multiple ways to get involved, from signing petitions to emailing planning officers directly. The timeline of events, from the Architects’ Journal coverage to the recent Development Control Forum, shows this is a living, breathing campaign. I love how they highlight that a new library is supported, but this specific design is the issue. The visual evidence and the clear contrast between the historic Bodley and the looming new structure make the case very compelling. It is wonderful to see citizens stepping up to protect the shared heritage of the city. This group is doing amazing work to ensure the college answers to the town.
Reading through the campaign materials reveals a clear, logical argument for preserving Cambridge’s historic streetscape. The detailed explanation of how the proposed structure impacts the Bodley Library provides excellent context for understanding the scale of the concern.
News
No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.
Photos
Widgets
Get the widget for your site →About Christ’s Lane Action Group
Christ’s Lane Action Group is a community campaign organisation based in Cambridge that opposes a proposed extension to Christ’s College Library along Christ’s Lane. The group is organising a petition, supporting a judicial review of the original planning permission (case AC-2025-LON-004656), and encouraging the public to object to a subsequent planning application (reference 26/02109/FUL). Its website presents the campaign’s arguments regarding heritage harm, daylight and sunlight impacts, and alternative proposals. The site provides court documents, campaign materials, a news section, and guidance on how to support the cause.
- Website
- christslaneactiongroup.org
- Categories
- Law practice, Civic & social organization