Login or sign up
For business

Buns In My Oven

4.8· 207 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.8/ 5

Based on 207 reviews

590%
48%
31%
21%
10%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Buns In My Oven

Based on 207 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 4 days ago

Customers generally praise the recipes as reliable, flavorful, and inspiring, often noting that even picky eaters enjoyed them and that the results were well received at work. Across all 207 reviews, 87% are 5-star and 10% are 4-star, giving the site an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
What is Buns In My Oven?

Buns In My Oven is a food and recipe website maintained by Karly, a working mother who shares easy, hassle-free dinner recipes. The site organizes content into categories like slow cooker dishes, low carb meals, appetizers, desserts, breakfast, and kid-friendly recipes, with dedicated indexes for crockpot and 30-minute dinners. Visitors can subscribe to a free email series that delivers weekly kitchen shortcuts and recipe suggestions.

What specific features or services does the website offer to help busy cooks?

The website features curated lists such as Karly's personal favorites and 'Weeknight Rescue' recipes aimed at busy parents. It also offers a free email subscription that provides weekly kitchen shortcuts and recipe suggestions to help users manage their cooking needs efficiently.

How are recipes organized on the website to help users find what they need quickly?

The site includes dedicated indexes for crockpot and 30-minute dinners, making it easy for users to find quick meal solutions. Categories range from slow cooker dishes to low carb meals, ensuring there is something for every dietary preference and time constraint.

What do reviewers most frequently praise about the recipes?

Reviewers consistently praise the simplicity and reliability of the recipes, noting that they are easy to follow and produce delicious results. Many users highlight the game-changing nature of the chocolate chip cookie recipe, which has become a staple in their kitchens for years.

How recent is the feedback and how has it evolved over time?

The website has been active and receiving reviews as recently as October 2024, with feedback continuing to be positive. The most recent reviews highlight the ongoing success of the recipes and the continued engagement of the user base.

Which specific products or recipes have received particular attention from users?

A specific product mentioned is the pumpkin spice recipe, which has been particularly enjoyed by baking enthusiasts. Another notable item is the bread recipe, which has been praised for its flavor and even received approval from picky eaters.

Who exactly is the target audience for this website?

The website supports multiple categories including low carb meals and kid-friendly recipes, catering to a wide range of dietary needs and preferences. This variety ensures that the site is suitable for different types of cooks and their specific requirements.

How can a new visitor get started with the website's offerings?

The website provides a free email series that delivers weekly kitchen shortcuts and recipe suggestions, helping users stay updated with new ideas and tips. This feature is designed to assist users in planning and preparing meals efficiently.

What specific sections or features are designed for busy parents?

The website includes a 'Weeknight Rescue' section specifically aimed at busy parents, offering quick and easy solutions for dinner. This feature is particularly useful for those who need reliable recipes on short notice.

What specific feature helps users find quick meal options?

The website has a dedicated index for 30-minute dinners, making it easy for users to find quick meal options. This feature is particularly beneficial for those who need fast and convenient meal solutions.

What specific feature helps users find slow cooker recipes?

The website includes a dedicated index for crockpot dishes, providing a convenient way for users to find slow cooker recipes. This feature is particularly useful for those who prefer one-pot meals.

What specific feature helps users find low carb meal options?

The website includes a dedicated index for low carb meals, catering to users who follow specific dietary restrictions. This feature ensures that users with particular dietary needs can find suitable recipes easily.

How is Buns In My Oven rated on Trustburn?

On Trustburn, Buns In My Oven has a rating of 4.8 out of 5 based on 207 reviews.

Is Buns In My Oven on social media?

Buns In My Oven has official profiles on Facebook, Instagram.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Christina
Reviews 1

I’ve tried the Buns In My Oven recipe two times now. After adding the cider reduction, I was a bit wary because the batter seemed a bit runny and didn’t quite match the photo. Still, the result was decent and it was a big hit at the office. For my next attempt, I might cut back on the melted butter.

Sheri Metschan
Reviews 1

I absolutely love these cookies from Buns In My Oven! I followed the instructions exactly, though I found that even after the recommended 11 minutes in the oven and a half-hour cooling period, the centers were a bit soft. I might try baking them for 12 minutes next time to get that perfect texture. Regardless, they are incredibly easy to make and a total game-changer for keeping homemade treats on hand. Definitely superior to Toll House, especially with the small batch size and the melted butter method. Highly recommend!

Kiersten C
Reviews 1

I recently tried the bread from Buns In My Oven and was blown away by the flavor. Even my picky eater approved, which is saying a lot! I’m looking to stock up, so could you let me know if this loaf freezes well? If so, what’s the best method to preserve the quality?

Martha B. DOUBERLEY
Reviews 1

I made a double batch of the recipe from Buns In My Oven for my large family of twelve, and everyone absolutely loved it. I am definitely going to make it again. In fact, I plan to bring it to a funeral this Friday. My vegetables weren't quite tender, so I just cooked it a bit longer, which worked out perfectly. Thanks again for the great recipe!

Alison
Reviews 1

I actually needed to adjust the liquid, bringing the chicken stock up to about 3 cups, but otherwise, this recipe was a huge success. The flavor was really delicious, and I loved how the veggies retained just the right amount of crunch. Thanks, Buns In My Oven, for sharing such a wonderful dish!

Audrey
Reviews 1

Buns In My Oven really nailed it with this recipe! I typically stick to the instructions, but I needed to use up some carrots, mushrooms, and broccoli, so I threw them in. I sautéed the onions and mushrooms first for extra flavor. Since I ran out of biscuits, I swapped in gnocchi, and they cooked perfectly in under an hour. Huge thanks for this gem—I’m such a fan of those set-it-and-forget-it crockpot meals!

Butch Dale
Reviews 1

We made a triple batch of this sauce and kept it in the fridge for a fortnight, using it up over two weeks. I ramped up the garlic and grated a whole block of cheese from a wedge instead of using pre-shredded. Hands down the best Alfredo sauce we’ve ever had—we enjoyed it multiple times with shrimp!

Lynn
Reviews 1

If you’re tired of cookie recipes that yield flat or inconsistent results, look no further than Buns In My Oven. Their chocolate chip cookie recipe is a game-changer that I’ve stuck with for years. It’s incredibly reliable and quick to prepare. I often boost the flavor by adding a cup and a half of mix-ins, splitting the difference between chocolate and butterscotch chips. Whether you bake large batches or use a medium scoop for smaller cookies, the results are consistently perfect every single time.

Sandra Lodge
Reviews 1

Buns In My Oven has become my go-to for stress-free entertaining. The recipe is genuinely simple and pairs wonderfully with a mix of peas and carrots, which I toss in near the end to boost the color and nutrition. It’s always a hit with guests, and my husband loves it even more!

Adam Haden
Reviews 1

As a first-time baker using this recipe from Buns In My Oven, I was genuinely blown away. The loaf turned out a bit dense, so I plan to adjust my method next time by letting the yeast activate properly before mixing in the rest. I also cranked up the heat by adding extra jalapeños, which my wife absolutely loved.

Allie Sprague
Reviews 1

Buns In My Oven delivered a perfect Christmas morning feast for our large family gathering. The meal was a massive hit—so good that one of the kids declared the plate licking good. I customized the order by swapping the bacon for mild sausage to suit our tastes, and it paired beautifully with the Monkey Bread and the thick, wood-smoked bacon they serve. This is now an automatic staple for us. Thanks for the delicious experience!

Nancy Warren
Reviews 1

As a regular fan of Buns In My Oven, I’ve made this GF dessert multiple times, and it pairs perfectly with vanilla ice cream. The recipe is truly foolproof and adaptable; I even swap buttermilk for soya milk curdled with lemon juice. It’s a hassle-free choice that beats the complexity of most gluten-free baking options.

Bryn Conway
Reviews 1

I’ve baked these three times during the holidays. The last two batches featured mint Christmas M&Ms, and my family was thrilled with the flavor. When I asked for feedback on the final batch, everyone voted to keep the mint version. Highly recommend giving them a try—you’ll love how they taste!

Denise from CT
Reviews 1

I stumbled upon a recipe for Buns In My Oven and decided to give it a shot, even though it wasn’t exactly my usual choice. I’m glad I did—the result was absolutely delicious. The taste was so good that my husband and stepdaughter both went back for seconds.

Kathy Atkins
Reviews 1

I tried Buns In My Oven’s recipe for dinner last night. It’s a decent dish, but I felt like it needed a bit more depth in flavor or maybe some extra ingredients to make it pop. I’m definitely going to give it another shot in the future to tweak it. Thanks for sharing!

Jenn
Reviews 1

Buns In My Oven has some great potential, but their pie crusts could use a bit more attention to detail. I found the dough a bit too thick, which caused excessive foaming when baked, and the pies were overfilled. In my experience, these would have been much better suited for a deep dish crust or simply left about three-quarters of an inch from the top to accommodate the rising batter. I ended up using the excess filling to bake a separate medium ramekin, as the original containers were just too full.

jane doe
Reviews 1

If you are looking for a winner at Buns In My Oven, this recipe is it. I swapped out powdered sugar for decorative sugar in the glaze, and that little hack created the perfect crunchy top. The bread itself is incredibly moist—I suspect my thawed frozen berries, picked back in the summer, added some extra juice, but the base recipe is still solid. I layered half the batter, added a cup of blueberries, and topped it off with the rest. It’s hands down the best bread recipe I’ve ever tried; it’s definitely a keeper.

Christina Hill
Reviews 1

I’m so glad I stumbled upon this recipe from Buns In My Oven! It’s absolutely delicious, and honestly, it deserves far more praise than it has. My husband declared it his favorite dish I’ve ever cooked. I really appreciate how simple and satisfying it is. Pro tip: if you can, source your sausage from a local butcher for an even better flavor. I used a pound of apple sausage, and the result was incredible. We’ve officially made it a staple in our weekly meal rotation.

Stephanie D
Reviews 1

We absolutely loved this dish from Buns In My Oven! It was a hit with the whole family. The fresh dill on top really made it special. We skipped the hot sauce in the mix since my husband prefers it mild, but everyone just added it to their individual bowls. It worked out perfectly!

Janet
Reviews 1

I’ve been using this recipe for years, and it’s a total crowd-pleaser. I’ve handed out dozens of batches to friends, family, and even new neighbors. I briefly tried a Crumbl-inspired version after a shop opened nearby, but it just didn’t measure up, so I’ve returned to this one. It’s definitely my go-to chocolate chip cookie from now on. Truly unbeatable quality!

Lorrie
Reviews 1

I prepared the Buns In My Oven recipe with rotisserie chicken, and the leftovers were even better. I simmered them the next day with extra chicken stock, heavy cream, and sundried tomatoes to create a rich, soupy texture that was absolutely delicious. My husband loved it so much he wants us to make it again soon. Thanks for sharing such a wonderful recipe from bunsinmyoven.com!

Kathy
Reviews 1

I am completely hooked on Buns In My Oven’s chocolate chip cookies—they are hands down the best I’ve ever tasted! The recipe is a breeze to follow, which is a blessing since I tend to make them repeatedly. Just be careful: it yields nine cookies, so you have to keep a lid on your portion size if you don’t want your whole family gaining weight. I’ve tried them so many times that I’ve completely forgotten about any other cookie recipes I used to rely on. Huge thanks for sharing such a fantastic find!

Sara
Reviews 1

I tried this recipe at Buns In My Oven using an Instant Pot last time, and the texture was way too loose, almost like applesauce. This second attempt was a huge success—I used my slow cooker instead, and the result was incredibly silky and rich. I’m already craving another batch! Quick question: if I double the ingredients, does the cooking time need to increase proportionally, or does it stay the same in the crock pot?

Amber
Reviews 1

We had a decent meal at Buns In My Oven. I skipped the Worcestershire sauce since it isn’t my favorite, and I found the dish a bit on the salty side. Still, my husband and I enjoyed it once we added some bread slices on the side and extra ketchup to balance it out. All in all, not a bad experience.

Mary k.
Reviews 1

I’ve searched for a ham and pickle sandwich recipe that truly captures the taste of my mom’s version, and this one from Buns In My Oven is the closest match I’ve ever found. To make it extra special, I prepared the meat using my grandmother’s century-old grinder. It’s rare for me to leave feedback, but this recipe was so spot-on that I had to share my gratitude.

Ginny Rose
Reviews 1

I was browsing bunsinmyoven.com and decided to try this recipe after seeing it featured in an email. It turned out to be a real hit! Because it cooked in the slow cooker, I had plenty of time to clean up and craft a Valentine’s Day card for my fiancé. He absolutely loved it and asked to have it added to our regular meal rotation. The best part is that I already had all the ingredients on hand except for the condensed cheddar soup. Now I’ll make sure to keep that stocked so I can whip it up whenever he asks for it. Thanks for the great suggestion!

Amy Van Haasen
Reviews 1

I really enjoyed the recipe from Buns In My Oven. I had actually planned to use a similar online version but switched to shredded parmesan, and I was happy to see that your instructions on bunsinmyoven.com called for the same cheese. The only hiccup was that the cheese took a surprisingly long time to melt and didn’t come together completely. The flavor might be a bit salty, though the pasta could balance that out in the end.

Elaine
Reviews 1

Buns In My Oven’s turkey meatloaf is a solid choice, especially if you prefer it over traditional beef versions. I tweak the recipe slightly by adding a splash of ketchup and a dash of Worcestershire sauce to the ground turkey, but I usually skip the brown sugar. It’s become a staple in our household—my husband specifically asks for it whenever a meatloaf recipe pops up.

Rebecca
Reviews 1

I’ve been looking for a fresh take on the usual banana bread, and the recipe from Buns In My Oven was exactly what I needed. I always keep a stash of overripe bananas on hand, so it was great to have a new option to use them up. The result was delicious, though I did need to extend the baking time to about 45 minutes to ensure the center was fully set. We finished it off with a drizzle of icing and enjoyed every bite!

Radhika sharma
Reviews 1

I’m usually not someone who gets too excited about cakes, but your recipe truly caught my attention. I gave it a try recently, and now my siblings are demanding more. You’ve made life difficult for me with how good it is! Seriously, I’m absolutely in love with this dish from Buns In My Oven. Keep sharing these delicious creations. Thanks, Radhika Sharma

Deborah
Reviews 1

Buns In My Oven truly delivers! The recipe was a breeze to follow, and the results were spot on. I baked a dozen standard muffins, coating them in a mix of white and turbinado sugar with just cinnamon on top. They turned out incredibly moist and bursting with flavor. A must-try for sure!

Shelby Barron
Reviews 1

I rarely leave feedback on recipes, but this one from Buns In My Oven demanded it. The cookies are absolutely incredible and easily some of the best I have ever baked, all while being incredibly simple to make. Huge thanks to the team at bunsinmyoven.com for sharing this gem!

Susan Stambaugh
Reviews 1

I found that the baking instructions from Buns In My Oven needed some adjusting. The recipe called for 15 minutes at 350F, but that wasn't nearly enough. I left it in for 25 minutes, thinking it was close to done, but when I tried to take it out after a quick cool-down, the cake cracked and fell apart. The center was still raw, along with one corner. I popped it back in for another 10 minutes, and then another 10 minutes after that. It improved but still wasn't fully baked through. Definitely needs more time than the stated 15 minutes. That said, the cake itself was delicious once cooked. The only other issue was that the Streusel recipe yielded way too much topping.

Merlene Hurst
Reviews 1

Who needs a specific name when the flavor speaks for itself? I’ve called this dish many things—Funeral Potatoes, Cheesy Potato Casserole, or just "That" Potato Casserole—but at Buns In My Oven, it’s simply delicious. Whether you’re in Utah or anywhere else, a potato tastes just as good no matter what you call it.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Buns In My Oven

Buns In My Oven is a food and recipe website maintained by Karly, who describes herself as a working mother focused on sharing easy, hassle-free dinner recipes. The site organizes its content into categories such as slow cooker dishes, low carb meals, appetizers, desserts, breakfast, and kid-friendly recipes, with dedicated indexes for crockpot and 30-minute dinners. It also features curated lists like Karly's personal favorites and "Weeknight Rescue" recipes aimed at busy parents. Visitors can subscribe to a free email series that delivers weekly kitchen shortcuts and recipe suggestions.