Login or sign up
For business

Boston Girl Bakes

4.9· 236 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.9/ 5

Based on 236 reviews

595%
42%
32%
21%
10%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Boston Girl Bakes

Based on 236 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 4 days ago

Customers generally describe Boston Girl Bakes recipes as something positive overall, praising flavors like pumpkin spice and vanilla, noting successful results even when adapting for dietary needs or missing equipment, and highlighting that the recipes are straightforward and accessible. The vast majority of reviewers rated their experience 5 out of 5, with only a small share giving lower marks.
What is Boston Girl Bakes?

Boston Girl Bakes is a food blog and recipe development business founded by Heather Farmer, a former Home Ec teacher. It provides approachable, from-scratch recipes for home bakers of every skill level, including cookies, cakes, breads, and quick breads. The site also offers baking tips, tested substitutions, and troubleshooting help to ensure 100% success in the kitchen.

How does the business generate content and partnerships?

The business partners with national brands such as Dove Chocolate, Quaker Oats, and Silk Creamer to provide value to its readers. It offers partnership opportunities in food photography, giveaways, product reviews, sponsored posts, and recipe development for brands that fit its baking focus.

What do reviewers consistently praise about the recipes?

Reviewers frequently praise the simplicity and dependability of the recipes, noting that the process is a breeze and accessible for first-time bakers. Many users highlight how the clear instructions and understanding of why steps matter help them avoid failures and build confidence.

What common themes emerge from the customer reviews?

Some reviewers mention that the recipes are so easy and straightforward that they make baking feel like having a supportive guide in the kitchen. Others note that the treats are perfect for beating the heat at parties and are an instant hit with everyone who tries them.

What are the stated terms for contacting or using the content?

The website states that the business does not accept link exchanges, text links, or written posts from businesses when determining its content strategy. It also notes that recipe questions should be left in the comment section of specific posts for faster responses.

What is the current rating and review volume?

The business has a Trustburn rating of 4.9 out of 5 from 236 reviews, with the most recent feedback dating back to October 2024. The overwhelming majority of recent comments are five-star ratings praising specific treats like biscuits, donuts, and cheesecakes.

Who is behind the recipes and what is her background?

Heather Farmer, the baker and recipe developer, spent seven years teaching Home Ec before becoming a full-time recipe developer. She believes that understanding why a recipe works is just as important as knowing what to do.

What specific baking techniques and tutorials are available?

The recipes include specific techniques such as how to soften cream cheese, knead dough, and peel peaches, along with tips for sifting flour and toasting coconut. The site also features a 'Baking 101' section to help beginners.

What specific products or recipes are featured?

The site offers a variety of specific recipes including small batch cheddar biscuits, mini turtle cheesecakes, pumpkin oatmeal cookies, and strawberry shortcake cake. It also categorizes recipes by method, such as no mixer, one bowl, and make ahead.

What additional resources are provided with the recipes?

The business provides tested substitutions, storage instructions, and troubleshooting help to ensure that home bakers can adapt recipes to their needs without guesswork. It also includes step-by-step photos to guide users through the process.

What is the core philosophy of the business?

The website states that the business focuses on scratch-made desserts and baking tutorials that allow people to grow their baking skills. It aims to show that baking from scratch does not need to be difficult or require a fancy pastry chef degree.

How can users interact with the business or use its content?

The site includes a contact section where users can request permission to use photos or adapt recipes, provided they link back to the specific post. It also outlines partnership opportunities for those looking to promote their brand.

How long has the business existed and what inspired it?

The business was founded after Heather Farmer took a culinary class on baking 10 years ago, which inspired her to start the blog. It has since grown into a resource helping hundreds of thousands of home bakers.

Where is the business located and who is it for?

The business is located outside Boston but grew up on a farm in upstate New York, though this does not affect the location of the blog itself. It serves home bakers globally through its website and social media platforms.

What is the official website of Boston Girl Bakes?

The official website of Boston Girl Bakes is bostongirlbakes.com.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Rebecca Wolters
Reviews 1

I recently tried my hand at baking homemade biscuits for the first time, and the results were fantastic. The process was incredibly straightforward, making it a breeze to prepare. Big thanks to Boston Girl Bakes for making such a delightful experience so accessible!

Marisa
Reviews 1

Boston Girl Bakes delivered exactly what we needed for our small family. While I adapted the recipe for mini muffins since I didn’t own a donut pan, the result was spot on. The pumpkin and spice balance was ideal, and that cinnamon-sugar coating truly rivals anything you’d get from a local bakery. I also appreciated that the portion size wasn’t overwhelming—just the right amount for us.

Lisa Williams
Reviews 1

Loved this recipe from Boston Girl Bakes! I managed to bake 23 of them at once using a mini muffin tin with just a tablespoon of batter in each cup. They came out perfectly in just 9 minutes at 325°F. The only tweak I plan to make next time is adding a thinner glaze on top. Thanks for sharing the recipe!

Rose Jennings
Reviews 1

If you’re a fan of pumpkin treats, Boston Girl Bakes has nailed it. These donuts are absolutely divine, especially when you melt butter into them and roll them in cinnamon sugar. They easily beat out any other pumpkin baked goods I’ve tried. Thanks for sharing the recipe!

Adri
Reviews 1

I am absolutely in love with the blueberry cream cheese pie from Boston Girl Bakes. The texture of the filling is incredibly smooth and silky. The blueberry topping hits the perfect note, with a touch of lemon that balances the flavors beautifully. It’s such an easy recipe that I’ll definitely be making it again soon!

Barb
Reviews 1

I had to improvise with parchment paper since I couldn’t track down an acetate ring nearby, which led to a slightly uneven slice and a bit of crumbling at the base. Also, three hours just isn’t enough time to properly thaw it out. That said, the flavor was spot on and the cake sprinkles are absolutely addictive—I could easily snack on a whole bowl of them. Thanks for the great recipe!

Dev
Reviews 1

I really appreciated the recipe from Boston Girl Bakes. I decided to make a double batch, which gave me enough batter for both a 9-inch cake and some cake pops to go. It did take quite a while to get everything done, and since I didn’t have an acetate cake ring on hand, I improvised by taping together a cardboard ring and lining it with parchment paper.

Angela
Reviews 1

Boston Girl Bakes understands that baking is as much about safety as it is about flavor. I recently used their guidance on home egg pasteurization and it truly transformed my kitchen routine. It’s a must-know for anyone making dishes with raw eggs, like my homemade Caesar dressing, as it significantly cuts down on foodborne illness risks. The steps were straightforward and easy to implement, giving me total peace of mind when serving my family. If you’re into making mayonnaise, mousses, or tiramisu right here in Boston, this tip from Boston Girl Bakes is an absolute game-changer.

Gianne
Reviews 1

I was genuinely impressed by how simple the process was at Boston Girl Bakes. The final product was incredibly moist and fluffy, exactly as promised. The vanilla flavor came through perfectly, and those colorful sprinkles added a lovely, fun touch to the presentation. I can’t wait to order from their site again!

Jackie
Reviews 1

If you are a purist like me who believes dark chocolate is the only real chocolate, Boston Girl Bakes nailed the doughnut. Their dark chocolate base batter is outstanding. Sure, it takes a bit more effort than a quick bake, but the payoff is huge. I couldn’t stop at one—finished three in one sitting!

Gianne
Reviews 1

Boston Girl Bakes has truly mastered the art of simplicity with their 3-ingredient pie crust. It’s incredibly straightforward to whip up and consistently delivers that perfect, buttery flakiness I crave. Whether I’m making a classic fruit pie or something savory, this crust has become an absolute staple in my kitchen routine.

Sharon
Reviews 1

Every Passover, Boston Girl Bakes’ coconut macaroon recipe is the centerpiece of our holiday table. I’ve also discovered a clever twist for lime tarts by using that same macaroon batter to create a crunchy crust for mini shells. After a quick ten-minute bake, I top the cooled shells with homemade lime curd and whipped cream. It is always a huge hit with the whole family!

Jenn S
Reviews 1

I’m totally hooked on this recipe from Boston Girl Bakes! I’ve whipped it up six times over the past few weeks because it’s just that good—we can’t seem to stop eating or sharing it. I swapped honey for molasses in the mix, but it turned out amazing. Thanks for the great recipe, Heather!

Lauren
Reviews 1

I’m struggling with the mixing technique in this Boston Girl Bakes recipe. The instructions say to beat the butter, shortening, sugars, eggs, oil, buttermilk, and vanilla on medium-high for 4–6 minutes until the mixture nearly doubles in size. However, mine just turns into a very yellow, soupy liquid and doesn’t increase in volume at all. I’ve been careful to add ingredients slowly, but I can’t seem to get that texture right. The final cake was edible but came out quite dense and gummy, which suggests something went wrong during that crucial mixing stage. I even retested with fresh ingredients and baked a backup cake for the party just to be safe. What am I missing here?

Brynlee
Reviews 1

I had a really delicious experience with Boston Girl Bakes! I decided to half the clementine recipe for this batch, but I underestimated the bake time. I pulled it out after 30 minutes, and the toothpick test came out dry, so the center remained a bit moist. That’s alright, though—it just means I’ll definitely be making this treat again! It’s such a tasty way to use up clementines.

Esther Krishnan
Reviews 1

Thanks for the baking advice! I followed your tip and used all-purpose flour for my chocolate chip cookies, and they turned out perfectly crispy without crumbling. The store-bought ones I tried were fragrant and crisp too, but they tended to break apart, so maybe it comes down to the recipe or baking method. Appreciate the help!

Harold Rail
Reviews 1

I decided to sprinkle some powdered chocolate into the dry mix, and the result was absolutely amazing. I just sampled the edge slice, and the flavor is truly incredible. If you’re a die-hard peanut butter fan, this loaf will be right up your alley. I was so confident I’d enjoy it that I doubled the batch to bake two loaves, and it was totally worth it. Honestly, this might be the best thing I’ve ever made. Thanks for sharing this wonderful recipe!

Elizabeth Brooks
Reviews 1

I found the baking soda flavor to be quite overpowering in the Boston Girl Bakes recipe. It was strong enough that my family could taste it clearly, even through the frosting. Next time, I’ll trust my gut and swap half the soda for baking powder, as I believe that adjustment would fix the problem. The current amount of two teaspoons really dominates the taste and smell. Just a heads-up for other bakers: be aware of that distinct soda aftertaste.

Laurie
Reviews 1

I’m impressed with how Boston Girl Bakes simplifies dessert making. This ice cream recipe takes just 15 minutes but delivers that slow-cooked, gourmet taste. The instructions are straightforward, resulting in a cookies and cream treat that beats any store-bought option. I’ll definitely be returning to this recipe.

Lauren
Reviews 1

Boston Girl Bakes, I’m back! Sorry for flooding your comment section. The cake was a total smash hit, and my family is already asking for the recipe. I had bookmarked this design for ages because it looked intimidating, but you made it so approachable. Would love to share photos! Thanks again for making baking fun and easy.

Elle white
Reviews 1

Boston Girl Bakes nails the flavor here—truly delicious! Yes, the dough is incredibly sticky, so I had to add some extra flour to handle it. It’s worth the tweak, especially since recipes often need adjustments based on location and elevation. The amount of milk called for was a bit much; cutting it in half would have been perfect. A baker who knows their dough knows exactly how to adapt. Curious where you’re baking from?

Jean
Reviews 1

Boston Girl Bakes nailed the flavor! I was so happy to find a dairy-free heavy cream and lactose-free condensed milk option—finally, ice cream I can actually enjoy. I stuck to 14 cookies, which felt like the right amount, though the batch was a bit stiff to scoop, so I might have messed up the mixing. Still, it tasted delicious.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Boston Girl Bakes

Categories
Food production