Login or sign up
For business

Beyond Frosting

4.8· 396 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.8/ 5

Based on 396 reviews

592%
42%
32%
21%
13%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Beyond Frosting

Based on 396 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 4 days ago

Customers generally find the recipes helpful and accessible, with many praising the clear instructions, accurate textures, and delicious results for items like cookies and cakes.
What is Beyond Frosting?

Beyond Frosting is a food & beverages listed on Trustburn. Beyond Frosting is a website that publishes dessert recipes aimed at home cooks. The site uses a recipe card format to present instructions, ingredients, and related details for making desserts.

What questions did Reddit users ask about Beyond Frosting recipes?

Some users on Reddit asked for tips on making a Devil's food cake with crushed Oreos for color contrast and construction vehicle toppers, while others shared their experiences making buttercream transfers for birthday cakes using the site's tutorials.

How does the recipe card format work on the website?

The recipe card format allows users to easily access instructions, ingredients, and related details for making desserts, with additional features like ratings, printable views, and sharing options available for each recipe.

What common complaints did reviewers mention about the baking process?

Some reviewers complained that the cupcake recipe isn't worth the effort because following the suggested bake time results in undercooked centers, while extending the time makes the tops too tough.

What specific product variations are available on the site?

The site includes a 9x13 version of a cake recipe that one user skipped the lemon extract for, relying instead on the zest and fresh juice to provide a perfect citrus kick without altering the flavor profile.

How does the scaling process work for larger batches?

The process involves scaling the recipe to 1.5x to bake a three-tier cake, as one user did for a birthday party, resulting in a crowd-pleasing dessert that went down as the best cake many guests had ever tasted.

What unique ingredients or layers are featured in the recipes?

The recipe for the Oreo cake includes a chocolate feuilletine crunch layer in the middle, as one user attempted to create a showstopper for their son's birthday, combining it with an icing transfer technique.

What types of desserts are available on the site?

The site offers a variety of desserts including cakes, cookies, donuts, and cheesecakes, with specific mentions of pumpkin season treats and autumn-themed recipes that are ideal for seasonal celebrations.

What specific dietary preferences are accommodated by the recipes?

The site provides a recipe for cocoa powder brownies that one user found suitable for someone who prefers mild sweetness but still enjoys fudgy and gooey textures, addressing common dietary preferences.

How is Beyond Frosting rated on Trustburn?

On Trustburn, Beyond Frosting has a rating of 4.8 out of 5 based on 396 reviews.

Is Beyond Frosting on social media?

Beyond Frosting has official profiles on Facebook, Instagram, Youtube.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Kaleia Davis
Reviews 1

I’m really impressed with the texture of this cake from Beyond Frosting. I baked it for a young girl I babysit, and the coconut flavor was spot-on—delicate enough to not overwhelm, but present enough to be delicious. Pairing it with our homemade lemon cream cheese frosting was a fantastic choice. A solid recipe!

Julia
Reviews 1

Beyond Frosting really nailed it with their chocolate chip cookies! As a 13-year-old who bakes often, I’ve tested plenty of recipes, but this one is a standout. The texture is spot-on—perfectly chewy with a nice crumble—and they taste just like childhood memories. I’m thrilled I stumbled upon this brand and can’t recommend them enough! 🙌🏼

Maryann Herrera
Reviews 1

I finally found the holy grail for 6-inch chocolate cakes after testing countless variations. This recipe genuinely stands out. The crumb is incredibly moist, and the chocolate taste is rich without being overly sweet. If you’re wondering about the coffee, don’t worry—it doesn’t turn it into mocha; it simply enhances the depth of the chocolate flavor. The frosting ratio is spot-on, covering the cake perfectly without needing extra. It was a huge hit at my husband’s birthday at Beyond Frosting!

SM
Reviews 1

I had a wonderful experience ordering from Beyond Frosting in Chicago. The cake tasted like a delicious hybrid of poke cake and tres leches, and it actually improved after sitting in the fridge for a day. I’m usually skeptical of cream cheese frostings because they can be too heavy, but theirs was perfect—the whipped cream added a lovely lightness and depth to the flavor. I tweaked the preparation by using an immersion blender to emulsify the strawberries during cooking, which helped the sauce soak deeper into the cake, and I finished it with crushed dried strawberries for an extra burst of flavor. I skipped the box mix and baked my own moist vanilla cake base using Julianne’s recipe, which turned out fantastic. I’ll definitely be ordering again.

Sasha H.
Reviews 1

Pumpkin season is officially here, and I needed a showstopper to bring to work. I found this recipe and decided to give it a shot for a welcome-to-fall treat. It definitely took some effort, but the result was totally worth it. I added a splash of Blackland Texspresso Bourbon that I had on hand, and it elevated the flavor beautifully. The whole office was impressed—my coworker actually got emotional! The pumpkin taste is subtle and well-balanced, so it doesn’t overpower the other notes. Even people who aren’t usually big fans of pumpkin really enjoyed them. The cupcakes are moist, light, and have that cozy, earthy autumn vibe. They look stunning on social media, too, and I’ve been enjoying them with my daily coffee. If I had one tip, it would be to use high-quality ingredients; the sophisticated flavor profile really shines through. Thanks for a great recipe!

Kelley Bryan
Reviews 1

I tried the cake from Beyond Frosting and it really hit the spot—so moist and perfectly balanced without being too sweet. I’m already baking another one tonight for dessert. It’s an ideal autumn treat, honestly even better than banana bread. Highly recommend!

Mel
Reviews 1

I ordered a cheesecake from Beyond Frosting yesterday and it was absolutely delicious. It was such a hit that I’ve definitely made it my go-to dessert. I topped it with homemade whipped cream and some blueberries and raspberries. The only issue was that there was only one slice left for me afterward!

Martha Dow
Reviews 1

We whipped up this treat for a birthday party last weekend. I scaled the recipe to 1.5x to bake a three-tier cake for Beyond Frosting. The crowd went wild—so many guests asked for seconds, and it easily went down as the best cake they’ve ever tasted. I wish I could share a photo!

Lynda August
Reviews 1

As someone in my sixties who has baked countless cookie variations over the years, I am always on the hunt for the next great flavor. The Oatmeal Raisin cookies from Beyond Frosting are an absolute standout! I followed their recipe exactly, and the result was pure perfection. Even though I usually stick to familiar ingredients, I highly recommend giving this one a try—you won’t regret it. Thanks for sharing such a unique recipe with the world, Beyond Frosting! Keep them coming!

SaintsBaker
Reviews 1

I recently baked the 9x13 version of this cake from Beyond Frosting, skipping the lemon extract since the zest and fresh juice already provided the perfect citrus kick. It’s another delicious success from Julianne’s collection. I rely on beyondfrosting.com as my go-to source for outstanding dessert recipes!

Kimani
Reviews 1

I whipped up these oatmeal raisin cookies on a whim because I was craving something soft, delicious, and easy to make. They definitely delivered on all fronts. I was really impressed by the weighted measurements, which made halving the batch a breeze. I do plan to add these to my regular rotation of recipes. My only hiccup was that the cookies spread quite a bit in the oven, but I suspect that was just user error. I’ll be trying again after chilling the dough in the fridge to see if that helps them hold their shape better.

Cristina
Reviews 1

I’ve relied on this recipe so often that I now have it memorized. It’s consistently a hit with friends and family who always rave about it. I recently baked a batch with butterscotch frosting using the Beyond Frosting method, and the results were absolutely delicious. A true staple in my kitchen.

Laura Carroll
Reviews 1

Beyond Frosting truly knocked it out of the park with these oatmeal raisin cookies. I was blown away by how good they tasted. Even my incredibly picky six-year-old neighbor, who rarely eats anything, devoured three of them and came knocking right away asking for more. I’m definitely making them a permanent staple in my baking routine!

Clint L
Reviews 1

I tried the pumpkin spice donut recipe from Beyond Frosting, and the result was just okay. The batter ended up too thin, which made it hard to get a proper rise for a cake-style donut. You’ll need to bake them for about 10 to 15 minutes, and while the process is straightforward, the final product didn’t quite live up to other pumpkin spice donut options I’ve tried.

Veronica Kimso
Reviews 1

I whipped up a batch of Beyond Frosting last night for a family reunion cake, and the results were excellent. I’m planning a 10-inch tier for the middle section of a three-tier cake (with dummy cakes on the top and bottom), but I’m wondering if I should double the recipe to properly fill that 10-inch pan.

Judy Pierce
Reviews 1

I just baked an 8-inch, three-layer Chocolate Mocha Cake from Beyond Frosting’s recipe for my daughter’s birthday. We’ve relied on a similar recipe for years, but mine always felt a bit dry, so I decided to give theirs a try. I was surprised to learn that bringing all ingredients to room temperature makes a difference—I hadn’t known that before! The result was incredible: the cake was incredibly fluffy and moist. I topped it with dark chocolate fudge frosting and only plan to reduce the espresso powder slightly next time; otherwise, it’s perfect. Even though we live at an altitude over a mile high, I only adjusted the oven temperature to 360 degrees and shortened the baking time, and it turned out delicious.

Lynn
Reviews 1

I stuck exactly to the instructions for the Beyond Frosting recipe, but the result was a total miss. The saltiness was overpowering to the point where it was barely edible, and it definitely needed way more sugar to balance it out. It’s a shame the flavor profile was so off since the product wasn’t cheap.

Debbie
Reviews 1

I was thoroughly impressed by this treat from Beyond Frosting. It delivers that classic pie flavor profile but skips the crust entirely. The base ice cream was already delicious on its own before the peach puree was even folded in. I swapped in lactose-free whole milk and heavy cream, and honestly, it didn’t affect the texture or taste one bit. I also tossed in some glazed pecans, which provided a lovely crunch and really elevated the dish. It’s a fantastic solution for using up peaches that are ripening too fast. Thanks to this recipe, my ice cream maker hasn’t seen such good use in a while—I’m already prepping ingredients for a second batch before the first one is even gone. I’d guess this works just as well with apples or pears, too.

Gina
Reviews 1

I baked a two-layer quarter sheet cake using this recipe—specifically, I doubled the batter but stuck to a single batch of the frosting and filling. I opted to skip toasting the coconut since it was requested plain, but the result was still delicious. I’m planning to share a photo of the finished cake, though I’m currently unsure how to upload it here.

Donna
Reviews 1

I’m usually pretty hesitant to leave reviews for recipes, but I make an exception when the result is truly stellar. I didn’t have enough raisins on hand, so I swapped in some chocolate chips instead. Beyond Frosting’s base recipe is fantastic—it has perfect ratios and clear instructions, making it so easy to customize. Next time, though, I’ll make sure to stock up on the full two cups of raisins! Thanks for the great tip.

karenf
Reviews 1

I was ready to give this recipe five stars just for inspiring me to buy some bourbon! While I substituted my own caramel buttercream, I followed the baking instructions to the letter and the result was a huge success. I shared it with five people, and they all agreed it’s a keeper. Thanks, Beyond Frosting!

Darlene Bobik
Reviews 1

I’ve been making the Beyond Frosting recipe on repeat and it’s been a hit! I’m curious if fresh peaches would work as a substitute for the strawberries, assuming I follow the same steps for the puree? Would appreciate your thoughts on that. Really enjoying the recipe so far—Dar

Jazmine
Reviews 1

I just tried this recipe for the first time and I am completely obsessed. The cake texture is spot on, and I really loved the tips for substitutions since I had to whip up my own buttermilk using almond milk and lemon juice. I personally found the frosting slightly less sweet than I prefer, so I added an extra half cup of powdered sugar to get it just right. I know I’ll be baking this one over and over again every year. Huge thanks to Beyond Frosting for sharing such a wonderful recipe!

Karen
Reviews 1

I actually took the time to go through all your detailed information and watch the video instead of just jumping straight to the instructions. I’ve tried this recipe from Beyond Frosting before, but it turned out significantly better this time around. I really believe the key was using cold butter and extending the mixing time. Thanks for providing such thorough guidance—I’ll definitely be baking this again!

CE
Reviews 1

The batter at Beyond Frosting is incredibly light and airy—I seriously considered just finishing the whole bowl myself! It works beautifully in a standard bundt pan and delivers a truly solid result. I swapped the whole milk for whipping cream, and it turned out absolutely delicious. A fantastic recipe!

Susanna
Reviews 1

I’m ready to award this five stars, provided you follow a crucial tip to avoid the recipe’s one pitfall. I baked this for a recent potluck and it was a huge hit. To fix the texture issue mentioned in that lone negative review, I went with a classic tres leches approach. I soaked the cake with a mix of sweetened condensed milk, whole milk, and evaporated milk, letting it sit in the fridge for an hour before adding the whipped topping. The result was absolute perfection. Thanks to Beyond Frosting for the great base recipe!

Jon
Reviews 1

Beyond Frosting’s lemon cookies are absolutely incredible. They’re simple to prepare, and I enjoyed mixing up the presentation by rolling half the batch in sugar and glazing the rest with extra lemon icing. The combination was a hit with everyone who tried them; the entire tray disappeared within a couple of hours. This is now my go-to recipe for lemon treats.

Goldy Roth
Reviews 1

I’m absolutely blown away by this buttercream recipe from Beyond Frosting. It’s hands down the best I’ve ever made. The instructions are so clear and quick to follow, and the tip about using cold butter straight from the fridge is a game-changer—I love skipping the waiting time for softening. I really couldn’t ask for better results!

Jon
Reviews 1

Beyond Frosting has never let me down. I already adored their lemon flavor, so I was thrilled to try the strawberry version—it was an instant hit. The process is simple, fast, and tastes incredible. It’s become my go-to: I now hoard strawberry cake mixes whenever they’re on sale just to bake these amazing cookies.

LaDonna
Reviews 1

I was thrilled with how the Beyond Frosting turned out for my daughter’s fourth birthday. I substituted salted butter for the unsalted version called for in the recipe, simply cutting back on the added salt, and it worked beautifully. I whipped up two batches to frost a three-tier cake and a smaller one, using the icing to create vibrant multicolor rosettes. It was flawless, and I’m definitely going to rely on this recipe again.

Karen Camp
Reviews 1

Beyond Frosting has nailed it with this no-bake treat! It looks absolutely delicious and is super simple to whip up, especially for those hot days when you don’t want to heat up the kitchen. Thanks for sharing this gem, Karen Camp—can’t wait to give it a try! 😋

Sha
Reviews 1

Living in the shadow of aerosol cans, I’ve been spoiled by the ease of store-bought whipped cream, but once you taste the real deal, like what’s available at Beyond Frosting, it’s hard to go back. My mother-in-law taught me the classic powdered sugar and vanilla method, and while it’s a staple in our house, I’m currently trying to figure out the best stabilization technique for a strawberry crepe cake I’m making this weekend. I need something that holds its structure better than the traditional mix.

Colleen
Reviews 1

I keep coming back to this no-bake cheesecake recipe from Beyond Frosting as my go-to. Since I’m obsessed with lemon flavors, adding that tangy twist to the creamy base was a game-changer. It’s incredibly simple to whip up, and I’ve never had a failed attempt—it’s consistently delicious. It’s become my top suggestion for friends looking for something easy yet impressive, and it’s always a crowd-pleaser. Thanks for sharing such a fantastic recipe!

Brenda
Reviews 1

I found it a bit tricky to prepare since I have Parkinson's, but I managed to get it done. It didn't look like much, and quite honestly, it looked a bit sad, but it was completely gone after the family gathering. Everyone should definitely try Beyond Frosting; the flavor was amazing. Thanks for the custom print!

Suzy
Reviews 1

I’m absolutely blown away by the cupcakes from Beyond Frosting. They might be some of the best I’ve ever tasted. The sponge was incredibly moist, and the filling hit the sweet spot—fluffy without being cloying. The icing was pure silk, smooth enough to pipe effortlessly. Everyone who saw them loved how beautiful they looked. I made a small error by skipping the coconut flakes in the batter, but I actually liked the texture better that way. The coconut extract in both the cake and filling was perfectly balanced, and the toasted coconut on top gave it a lovely crunch. Just a tip: chill them right after frosting. The icing is so delicate that they’re best served cold, though they’ll keep in the fridge for a few days. They really do taste like coconut cream pie. You nailed it! Thanks for sharing this recipe.

Kaitlyn
Reviews 1

Beyond Frosting truly lives up to its name. I found their buttercream to be absolutely outstanding—so good that I doubt I’ll ever need another recipe again. I made a slight adjustment by using salted butter, so I skipped the extra pinch of salt, but the result was still incredible.

Kimberly
Reviews 1

Beyond Frosting’s pumpkin pie filling is my go-to choice for the holidays and beyond. It delivers on both flavor and presentation, resulting in a dessert that tastes as good as it looks. I’m constantly getting compliments from guests, which makes all the effort worth it. Thanks for the great recipe!

Beth
Reviews 1

Beyond Frosting made a stunning cheesecake that truly lives up to the hype. As someone who doesn't consider themselves a baker, I found the process surprisingly straightforward, especially with the help of the crockpot liner. The flavor was out of this world—easily the best I’ve ever had—and the presentation was perfect.

AB
Reviews 1

As a beginner baker trying out Beyond Frosting’s recipes, I’m finding the instructions pretty helpful. I’m planning to bake two 8-inch cakes to create four layers, so could you clarify the measurements I should use for that? Also, if I decide to halve the recipe, does the cake mix and pudding mix amount get halved as well?

Cassie Winther
Reviews 1

I’m a regular customer of Beyond Frosting and have baked their mixes about six times now. The flavor is absolutely delicious, though I’ve struggled with the cookies spreading too much and ending up flat every single time. I take baking seriously—I used precise gram measurements for the dry ingredients, ensured the butter was perfectly softened, chilled the dough overnight, let it sit for 30 minutes at room temperature before baking, and even used parchment paper. Still, they end up flat. I just wish they had a better shape while keeping that amazing taste. Does anyone have any tips to fix this?

Kris
Reviews 1

I’m almost giving Beyond Frosting five stars, but I’ll save the final topping for when I’ve had more time to test. I had a couple of questions while browsing your site. First, your cake recipe says to follow the box instructions, but my box doesn’t list 22 minutes. I baked it until the skewer came out clean, but I’m wondering if that specific time helps keep the top flat, since mine ended up rounded. Second, I’ve been following you since 2017. As an Oregon foodie who moved from PDX to Tillamook and now lives in Eugene, I figured I’d support an Oregon-based site! Back in ’17, you mentioned never using gelatin in your whipped cream frosting, but the updated 2021 recipe includes it. My next attempt is your hot cocoa whipped cream recipe, which doesn’t use gelatin. Should I add it anyway? Thanks!

Molly
Reviews 1

Big thanks to the team at Beyond Frosting for being so patient with all my inquiries! I’ve decided to go with the pudding filling and pair it with your cream cheese whipped cream for the topping. The results look absolutely delicious—I can’t wait to give it a try.

Annemarie B mcNamara
Reviews 1

I recently discovered Beyond Frosting’s Coconut Cake and it was an instant hit. The moment I took that first bite, I knew I had found my new favorite recipe. My family absolutely loved it, too, and I’m already expecting requests for it every time. Truly a delicious cake!

Molly
Reviews 1

I was digging through some older reviews and noticed that Beyond Frosting’s classic recipe used condensed milk, whereas the current version relies on pudding mix. I’m curious about that switch—does the pudding offer a superior flavor profile, and how does the sweetness compare? I’m planning to bake this for my daughter’s upcoming birthday and am thrilled to give it a go, but I’m torn between the two fillings. I’ve also been thinking about adding cream cheese to the pudding base; have you experimented with that combination in your poke cakes before? Thanks for all your help!

Chloe
Reviews 1

I’ve tried baking cakes from scratch for my husband’s birthdays for years, and honestly, some of those attempts were disasters. He’s heard the "this year is different" promise so many times that his reaction is always a nervous "oh boy." This year, I switched to cupcakes, and the result was absolutely perfect. Great choice!

Jasmine
Reviews 1

I usually stick to recipes on this site because the comments guarantee they’re delicious, but I was inspired to try this one and wow! The creator is truly talented. These cupcakes turned out better than any others I’ve made over the years. I absolutely loved this recipe and will definitely be trying more of your creations.

P.
Reviews 1

I’m a hobby baker who usually gets recipes right, so I was thrilled to try this one. Unfortunately, the batter was too runny, the icing ended up way too thick, and the cooking time needed to be much longer than suggested. I followed the instructions to the letter and even read through the entire blog post, but the results just didn’t match up.

Lisa
Reviews 1

I recently tried the cookies from Beyond Frosting, leaving out the salt on top, and the result was absolutely phenomenal. The texture matched the description perfectly—incredibly soft and chewy with nice chunks. I swapped in milk chocolate chips because that’s what I had on hand, and they were just as tasty as I hoped. After sampling many chocolate chip cookie recipes, this one has definitely earned a permanent spot in my rotation.

Lauren S
Reviews 1

Lauren here! I’ve been using Beyond Frosting recipes for a while now—first for my brother’s wedding, where the cake turned out fantastic after a few practice runs, and even my coworkers were impressed. Recently, my son asked for it for his birthday, and I’m considering switching to cupcakes with piped curd centers. Does Beyond Frosting have any tips on adjusting the baking time for cupcakes compared to the standard cakes?

Kim
Reviews 1

Moisture is the real deal, and Beyond Frosting nails it. Too often, people praise a cake for its flavor profile while ignoring that the texture is dry as sand. You can have all the right ingredients, but if the crumb is dry, it just doesn’t matter. As someone who loves decorating more than baking, I’ve found that most cakes on Pinterest fall short in this department. Yours are in that rare top tier—actually moist. Thank you for the fantastic recipes!

Deb Frank
Reviews 1

I’ve tried quite a few doctored cake mixes, but the recipes from Beyond Frosting are in a league of their own. These cupcakes turned out incredibly light and fluffy, rising beautifully without any trouble. I tweaked the method slightly by folding in stiffly beaten egg whites to help them reach their full height in those deep daisy liners, and I experimented with both plain coconut and a batch studded with toasted pecans. They vanished instantly at a family get-together, with guests totally surprised to learn they were based on a cake mix. Everyone wanted the source, and I was happy to direct them to beyondfrosting.com. Thanks for such a reliable, time-saving solution that still delivers that homemade taste!

LeapofFaith Faith
Reviews 1

As a 70-year-old, I’ve spent my entire adult life wrestling with the mystery of how to bake thick, gooey chocolate chip cookies instead of the flat, sad discs I was making for decades. Thanks to Beyond Frosting, that struggle is finally over. I followed your recipe, adding a bit more vanilla and extra chocolate chips, and the result was absolutely perfect. The texture is exactly what I’ve been chasing. I’ve already shared your method with friends because I realized I’m definitely not the only one who needed this solution!

Mary
Reviews 1

I recently came across the recipes on Beyond Frosting and I am totally obsessed! The treats are so vibrant and playful, making them a massive hit with my family. Someone mentioned boosting the taste with strawberry preserves and extra Poptarts, so I’m really looking forward to trying that twist next.

Mom of Three
Reviews 1

I’m blown away by the quality of the cake from Beyond Frosting! I stuck to the homemade vanilla cake recipe and followed the instructions exactly, and the feedback from everyone who tasted it was incredible. This might just be the best cake I’ve ever baked. Big thanks to the team!

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Beyond Frosting

Beyond Frosting is a website that publishes dessert recipes aimed at home cooks. The site uses a recipe card format to present instructions, ingredients, and related details for making desserts. Its tagline, "Easy Dessert Recipes Anyone Can Make," indicates a focus on accessible baking and sweet treat instructions. The site includes features such as ratings, printable views, and sharing options for each recipe.