This service is so convenient for checking my trade logs! I just sent my CSV and rules, and got a detailed report back quickly. The scorecard and risk rankings are super helpful. I love that I can ask questions before buying. The whole process feels smooth and professional.
Questions about Backtest Evidence Review
What is Backtest Evidence Review?
Backtest Evidence Review is a Spain-based independent service that assesses a single algorithmic or quantitative trading backtest for €79. The reviewer evaluates documented out-of-sample design, costs, null or permutation tests, and sample size. The report is delivered within two business days after complete submission and accepted files.
Who exactly is this service for?
The service is designed for clients who need an independent second read of their backtest before trusting the results. It suits strategies submitted as trade-results spreadsheets or CSV exports along with written rules and cost assumptions. The reviewer does not rerun the strategy or generate new statistical tests during the assessment.
How can I get started or book a review?
Clients can get started by using the 'Ask first' feature, which opens a fit-check email draft without requiring a purchase. After payment verification via Stripe, the reviewer emails an intake form link and a private Proton Drive folder for file uploads. The process requires no API keys and handles up to two trade-log exports for platform/data migration checks.
What is the pricing and how do I pay?
The fixed price for one backtest review is €79, charged through a Stripe-hosted checkout. Payment is required before the intake and upload folder are provided. The service explicitly states that no signals or requests to 'make this profitable' are part of the scope.
How long does it take to get the report?
The report is delivered within two business days of complete submission and accepted files. The reviewer provides a methodology scorecard, five ranked evidence risks, and a suggested next experiment. The final output includes a verdict such as insufficient, exploratory, or ready to test on future unseen data.
What specific evidence does the reviewer assess?
The reviewer assesses whether the provided tests and evidence support the result, but does not rerun the strategy or generate new statistical tests. The service also offers an optional superficial review of up to 200 lines without running the code. A personal research lab pre-registers hypotheses before testing them.
Who runs the business and where is it located?
The business is located in Spain and is founded by Xavier Gisbert Blanquer, an independent methodology reviewer. The team operates as a single independent service rather than a large organization. The reviewer walks forward splits and pre-registers hypotheses in their own lab work.
What is the rating and how recent are the reviews?
The service has a Trustburn rating of 4.3 out of 5 from 4 reviews. The feedback is recent, with the listing showing a specific rating split based on these four customer experiences. The reviews highlight the reviewer's ability to identify failed gates in simulated out-of-sample profit.
Can you show an example of a failed review?
The H001 sample report documents a backtest that failed the reviewer's own gates. It showed simulated PnL of +113.92 on 1,000 start but failed the null test and sample gate. The verdict was insufficient evidence because the trade count was 13, which is less than the 15 required.
Are there special use cases for data migration?
The service allows optional use cases for platform/data migration evidence checks. This involves the same strategy and same window using up to two trade-log exports from platforms like MT4, MT5, or cTrader. The process requires no native platform integration.
How does this differ from other backtest services?
The business states that the reviewer assesses the out-of-sample design and null tests you document. The reviewer does not rerun strategies or generate new statistical tests during the review. The H001 sample report is one of six lab runs that all failed those gates.
What files do I need to prepare?
The service requires clients to submit one strategy in spreadsheet or CSV form. The reviewer needs written rules and cost assumptions along with the trade-results data. The intake process happens after payment verification via Stripe.
How can I contact Backtest Evidence Review?
You can reach Backtest Evidence Review by e-mail at hello@backtestevidence.com.
What is the official website of Backtest Evidence Review?
The official website of Backtest Evidence Review is backtestevidence.com.
AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.
The review offers a fresh perspective on your backtest evidence. However, it is important to note that they do not run new tests or optimize your strategy, which limits the depth of the analysis. You receive a verdict and suggested experiments, but you must provide all the raw data and rules yourself. It is a useful sanity check for documentation rather than a deep dive into performance.
From what is listed, the review seems thorough, though the lack of reruns might leave some questioning the depth of the independent analysis provided.
The review process feels incredibly rigorous and transparent. I appreciated that they assessed the out-of-sample design and null tests I provided without rerunning the strategy or generating new statistical data. The report included a methodology scorecard and ranked evidence risks, which gave me a clear verdict on whether my evidence held up. It is not investment advice, just a solid check on your documentation.
News
No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.
Photos
No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.
Widgets
Get the widget for your site →About Backtest Evidence Review
Backtest Evidence Review is a Spain-based independent service that reviews a single algorithmic or quantitative trading backtest for €79, with a report delivered in two business days. The reviewer assesses the evidence provided by the client, including documented out-of-sample design, costs, null or permutation tests, and sample size, but does not rerun the strategy, generate new statistical tests, optimize it, or certify profitability. The service also publishes a personal research lab where hypotheses are pre-registered and tested, including a public worked example (H001) that documents a backtest that failed the reviewer's own gates. Clients submit one strategy in spreadsheet or CSV form along with written rules and cost assumptions through a Stripe-hosted checkout and a private Proton Drive folder. The service is explicitly described as not financial advice.
- Website
- backtestevidence.com
- Categories
- Financial services