Login or sign up
For business

Amy's Candy Kitchen

4.7· 294 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.7/ 5

Based on 294 reviews

584%
48%
33%
25%
10%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Amy's Candy Kitchen

Based on 294 reviews on Trustburn · updated 63 days ago

Customers generally describe Amy's Candy Kitchen very positively, frequently praising the quality of the caramel apples and chocolate and calling them the best they've had, while a few noted that prices felt steep for the size of the items.
What are the most common complaints about Amy's Candy Kitchen?

Based on the critical reviewers' comments, the most common complaints concern high prices and poor service; the 1-star reviewers described the candy as overpriced or burnt, the staff as rude or unhelpful, and one said no one was cheerful.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Kathy Pinkowsky
Reviews 1

Their candy is incredibly high quality. I love stopping in there for a small snack. If you like caramel/candy apples, this is the only place in Wisconsin for you to go! Their huge caramel apples can be split with a number of people, and they even pre-slice them for you. If you are a tourist in Cedarburg, this is one of the places you have to visit.

Brittany Jepson
Reviews 1

Hands down the best caramel apples and I don't even like caramel apples. What makes then so delicious and irresistible is the caramel it's so soft and smooth that it doesn't stick to your teeth. They COVER these apples in everything you can imagine from cookies to candy. My personal favorite is the cookie jar. We always make a point to stop when we are on the road for a snack!

Sebin
Reviews 1

I fell in love with this place when I attended my first strawberry festival about 5 years ago. Their apples are crisp. Their chocolate is divine. And honestly, you gain 5 lbs just from smelling the shop, but I don't care. Everything is always top quality and the workers are cheerful and helpful. 10/10 would recommend to everyone.

Christopher Grow
Reviews 1

I was recently gifted a couple of Amy's apples for my birthday. Hands down, one of the best birthday treats I've ever had. The dark chocolate with sea salt was amazing followed by an equally as good dark chocolate with roasted cashews. I swear that apple weighed 5 pounds! I can't wait to return the favor and share Amy's gourmet apples with friends and family. Such an amazing treat made right here in Wisconsin.

QueenKe's Creations
Reviews 1

I'm Sooooo Happy About My Order! I Had My Very First Order With Your Company And I'm Extremely Satisfied! At First When I Brought My Apple Online I Thought A $22.00 Apple Sounded Very Expensive. But When I Recieved My Apple. I Could See Why They're $22.00. I Definetly Got My Money's Worth! Thank You To The People Who Contributed To Creating Such A Perfect Apple.

Rita Krstulovich
Reviews 1

The best chocolate I've had in my life. No words cant describe the flavor, decadent like a piece of heaven in your mouth. Pricey but worth every penny....some things are worth the money and calories. If was was going to the electric chair this would be my last sweet treat.

Rob Crossley
Reviews 1

Amy's has the best Carmel apples in this area. The apples themselves are delicious granny smith apples, and the toppings come in a wide variety. If Carmel apples aren't your thing, there are delicious gummy candies, delightful truffles, and a whole slew of chocolate candies. You won't be disappointed.

Justin Molter
Reviews 1

The caramel apples are the best ones I've ever had. The chocolate and caramel are excellent. Super cool to have this place right in the heart of Cedarburg. The only downfall is that the apples are very pricy... If they cost a little less I would definitely buy them more often.

Dan Kluwe
Reviews 1

Truly the most delicious caramel apple I've ever tasted! I don't even like caramel and I could eat 100 of these! Lots of other wonderful candies and chocolates to choose from! Definitely well worth stopping in even just to look around. It would be really nice if there was nutrition info available for their products though.

So Thereitis
Reviews 1

Amy's is famous for many things, though the apples stand out, this little shop has big flavor, a family favorite and we find ourselves going here often. also makes a great gifts for others, though i will say this, sometimes the apples are not as ripe as the should be, other then that, no complaints.... well maybe price, it is a bit expensive for the amount / quality

Dan Cehanovich
Reviews 1

Probably one of the best candy shops in the state. The BEST chocolate and carmel covered apples you will find. Huge selection of apples, candies and all things chocolate. Amazing staff that will even cut the apple off the stick so u can enjoy it right away and easier to eat. Truly a gem of cedarburg.

Heidi Perry
Reviews 1

My husband and I roadtrip to Amy's twice a year. We drive about 220 miles for Amy's Carmel apples. Amy's Carmel apples are the best, hands down!! The smell of the store is amazing also! I wish I could capture the smell of the store to share like we share the apples with people at home. When we go to Amy's, we take orders from family and friends to make it worth the trip. Our last trip was on the 4th of July. The town of Cederberg was having a parade just in time that we came to town. We ended up walking all the way down the parade route to get to Amy's. There were tons of people watching the parade we had to get through. Amy's apples are worth the hassle. We ordered 20 apples, but checked out at different times so we didn't make anyone wait for us. We stepped aside many times to let people in front of us. Even though there was a parade outside, inside the store was not all that busy at that time. The young girl serving us was very rude to us! She stated the next time we come on a busy weekend we should call ahead with our order. We had no idea about the parade, remember were from 220 miles away. Our town doesn't celebrate the 4th of July. There were plenty of coworkers working that day and it's not like we wiped the clean of apples, they were filling the front window as fast as we were taking them! I feel the girls comment was un called for.

Andrew Gauger
Reviews 1

Best chocolate and candy place around... they make a lot of their own chocolate and caramel on site... you can watch them do it and (yum) smell the results. Often has chocolate covered strawberries, made with the biggest strawberries have ever seen. They specialize in chocolate covered giant apples made with a dozen different chocolate, carmel, nuts and candy combinations. Try the Belgium chocolate caramels! Nummmmy stuff!!!

Emily Ewe
Reviews 1

A must visit if you're in Cedarburg! They have the most wonderful variety and quality of Caramal Apples! A perfect gift, dessert, or just because! There's also handmade and prepackaged candies. It's a self serve with tray pans from the front display windows for apples. Fudges, brittles, turtles and other smaller handmade items are served from behind the bakers counters. They will chop the apple for you upon request. Normally very busy but the staff keep it clean and the line is always moving.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Amy's Candy Kitchen