Login or sign up
For business

Amanda's Cookin'

4.7· 744 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.7/ 5

Based on 744 reviews

581%
410%
31%
23%
15%
Ask AI

What reviewers say about Amanda's Cookin'

Based on 744 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 2 days ago

Customers generally find the recipes simple and tasty, with many praising the ease of use and good flavor, though some note that certain items like bread dough can be challenging to handle or that seasonings may be salty.
What is Amanda's Cookin'?

Amanda's Cookin' is a business listed on Trustburn.

What is the official website of Amanda's Cookin'?

The official website of Amanda's Cookin' is amandascookin.com.

How is Amanda's Cookin' rated on Trustburn?

On Trustburn, Amanda's Cookin' has a rating of 4.7 out of 5 based on 744 reviews.

Is Amanda's Cookin' on social media?

Amanda's Cookin' has official profiles on Linkedin, Facebook, Instagram, Youtube.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Mark
Reviews 1

I found Amanda's Cookin' to be a solid choice, though the seasoning is definitely on the salty side. I’ve found that using slightly less than half a portion keeps the sodium in check and delivers a perfect flavor. It might also depend on the specific blend, like the Ragin’ Cajun mix, but overall it’s a good product if you watch your portions.

K. Page
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' really missed the mark on this one. The macaroni had a gummy texture that just didn't work, and the sauce was far too thin. The flavor was pretty underwhelming, so I tried popping it in the oven for a bit to see if it could be salvaged, but it was a bit of a letdown.

Julie
Reviews 1

Amanda, I owe you an apology because I can’t honestly give this dish the high rating it’s been given. I clicked on Amanda's Cookin' with high hopes after seeing those impressive 4.97 stars from 65 reviews, but my experience was a total letdown. The ingredient list is extensive, requiring you to julienne and dice quite a few items, and the promised 25-minute prep time is a stretch—it took me a solid 45 minutes, and it wasn’t effortless by any means. You’d expect a recipe with that kind of rating to be fantastic, but this casserole was incredibly bland. The chow mein noodles on top were dull both in appearance and flavor. I’m really frustrated because the recipe makes a huge portion, so I’m stuck eating leftovers that I’m dreading. To make matters worse, my stomach is already acting up after the first serving. It simply doesn’t deserve a 4.97-star rating.

Christina
Reviews 1

If your dad is a pineapple fan looking for a lighter alternative to heavy desserts, Amanda's Cookin' is a fantastic choice. We started ordering this dessert a couple of years ago and it quickly became his absolute favorite. It has officially replaced the traditional cakes as our go-to for his birthday celebrations and is also a reliable hit at summer potlucks. Great job sharing this delicious treat!

Caroline
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' delivered on a truly excellent recipe. While I initially struggled with the flour-to-dough ratio, trying to visually match the provided photo, I found the instructions forgiving enough that it was nearly impossible to mess up. My batch may not have been flawless, but the result was fantastic. A solid 10/10 experience.

Mary
Reviews 1

I rarely share my cooking experiences online, but Amanda's Cookin' really earned a mention this time. The roast came out perfectly tender and juicy, with that rich, caramelized mirepoix sauce that really ties the dish together. I’m definitely adding this to my regular rotation. Just a tip for others: I used a bone-in sirloin instead of the suggested cut, and it worked out just fine!

Leah
Reviews 1

I’ve prepared Amanda’s Cookin’ recipe over a dozen times now, and it never fails to deliver. As devoted fans of Claussen pickles, I can confidently say this version tastes just as authentic. I usually bump up the garlic and toss in a red pepper for an extra kick. If you want to avoid soft, mushy results, do yourself a favor and don’t skip the pickle crisper—it really makes a difference. Every time, I end up with crisp, tangy, garlicky pickles that hit the spot. Thanks for sharing this fantastic recipe!

Laura
Reviews 1

After half a century of baking, I stumbled upon Amanda's Cookin' and found a technique I’d never encountered before. I decided to test it out, and the results were flawless. The dough felt wonderful to handle, and the final loaf was an instant hit with my grandchildren. I also found the note on the distinction between French and Italian bread to be a delightful bonus—definitely worth a re-read if you haven’t noticed it yet.

Sherry
Reviews 1

I’ve been checking out Amanda's Cookin' for a few years now, and my family always finds recipes we adore. Thanks for consistently sharing such wonderful meals, sides, and desserts. My husband declared this the best banana cake he’s ever had—moist and full of flavor—and he said the brown butter really took it to the next level.

Lisa H
Reviews 1

I recently tried Amanda’s Cookin’ mac and cheese in the slow cooker. Instead of grating, I cubed the block cheese and cooked it on low for an hour and fifteen minutes, leaving the lid loose and stirring every fifteen minutes. While the final texture was a bit gritty—possibly from the heat—the flavor was excellent and everyone enjoyed it. I really appreciated the unique addition of evaporated milk and spices, which is a nice twist compared to standard baked recipes.

Gabe J
Reviews 1

I’m really impressed with this loaf from Amanda's Cookin'. I’ve baked it twice already, experimenting with a mix of all-purpose and bread flour. The dough is incredibly easy to work with, resulting in that wonderful soft, springy texture I love. For the first batch, I used a cast iron skillet with a water pan in the oven to get a crunchier crust, and even though I skipped that trick the second time, it was still absolutely delicious. Great recipe!

Lucinda Terry
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' really nailed it with this one! I’m surprised more people aren’t giving this five stars. It’s become a permanent fixture in my kitchen now because it’s just that good. My friend actually loves it so much she calls it "Apple Baby," so now I hear "Can you make me some apple baby?" all the time. It’s such a versatile recipe that I’m thinking of getting creative with the topping—maybe swapping it for strawberry or blueberry next time. Truly excellent stuff. I’d give it ten stars if I could!

Ryan
Reviews 1

I don't leave many reviews, but this bread from Amanda's Cookin' is worth the mention. It bakes up into a perfect loaf that is incredibly versatile—you can use it for French toast, garlic bread, croutons, dressing, or just a classic sandwich. I wouldn't change a thing about it. Truly delicious.

Kim
Reviews 1

Working with Amanda's Cookin' recipes can be a bit of a mystery, and my recent experience with their loaf dough proves it. I pride myself on precision, so I calibrated my scale right before starting and measured everything in grams. Despite this care, the dough turned out incredibly sticky—far more hydrated than the ingredient list suggests. Even after adding the full amount of flour specified, plus an extra cup for handling, and then dumping in two more cups, the dough remained tacky. I let the mixer run for ten minutes to help develop the gluten, and it still felt wet. I suspect those who don't struggle with this are either in very dry regions like Arizona or, more likely, packing their flour by scooping it directly from the bag rather than spooning it in, effectively using double the required amount. I ended up manually folding the dough and shaping it with floured hands. Hopefully, the flavor makes up for the texture hassle, but I might need to double the flour in future attempts or try a different source.

Cathy Streimer
Reviews 1

As someone who bakes cookies regularly, I found these dry and hard, with an overpowering chocolate flavor that was too much even for a chocoholic like me. I followed the instructions carefully—double-checked the recipe—and still ended up tossing most of the batch. I’ve loved nearly every other recipe from Amanda’s Cookin’, but this one was a definite miss. I even tried keeping bread slices in the container to help soften them, but it didn’t make a difference. First time leaving a review, and it’s for this reason.

Jaime
Reviews 1

I am absolutely loving the bread from Amanda's Cookin'! It is hands down the best, easiest, and most delicious loaf I have ever baked. I wish I could give it more than five stars. This bread is simply perfect. Thank you for sharing such a wonderful recipe. I'm getting ready to make some sausage and peppers to put in sandwiches made with this bread.

SGK
Reviews 1

Amanda’s Cookin’ nailed it with this meatloaf. It’s consistent and delicious every time I make it. I used to cut corners, but I’ve learned that sticking to the core steps while adding my own little twists keeps the result perfect. It’s a quick and easy process—definitely worth the time. Thanks for the great recipe, Amanda!

Alyssa
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' provided a solid foundation with the pasta's nice thickness, though I felt the flavor profile needed a little more depth. It might just be a matter of personal preference when it comes to cheese selection. Thanks for the straightforward recipe—it gave me the right starting point to experiment and tweak it until I create a dish that really hits the spot. 🙂

Courtney A Stockin
Reviews 1

I tweaked the Amanda's Cookin' recipe by swapping out tomatoes for salsa and tossing in some Hatch chilies for extra kick. It seems like the tomatoes and cream of chicken really need to be blended together to work best; the layered flavors didn’t quite hit the mark on their own, but mixing them up made a huge difference. I’d also recommend using a full 10oz can of the cream of chicken soup for better results.

Irene Smith-Rice
Reviews 1

I’ve relied on Costco bread for ages since I’m not one for baking, so I was genuinely panicked when they stopped carrying it. My husband and I searched everywhere for a replacement that matched that specific taste and texture. Amanda's Cookin' recipe hit the mark perfectly. It’s incredibly simple to make, which is a huge plus for me. I really appreciate you sharing this; it’s definitely a keeper.

Kirsten
Reviews 1

I’m with you on this. I actually made Amanda's Cookin' dish twice, and both times the texture was off—kind of gritty, like the cheese didn’t incorporate smoothly. It didn’t match the appetizing photo at all, with visible chunks and a somewhat gunky appearance. I tried extending the cooking time to fix it, but that only dried it out before the pasta could really cook through. Still, the flavor was good; I just wish the consistency had been better.

Christiane Audette
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' really knows how to deliver on flavor and simplicity. I whipped up this dish using almond extract and walnuts, skipping the icing entirely, and it turned out absolutely delicious. It’s so straightforward to make that I’ll definitely be returning to this recipe. Thanks for the great inspiration!

Hugh Linton
Reviews 1

I recently tried the salad at Amanda's Cookin', and I'm impressed by how fresh it stays. They have a clever trick of mixing equal parts orange juice and ginger ale to dress it, which keeps the greens crisp and delicious for much longer than usual. A nice touch to their fresh offerings.

Bob T.
Reviews 1

I really can’t figure out why Amanda's Cookin' has such high ratings for this. The pickles end up soggy and completely lacking in flavor. Usually, you’d heat the brine to really pull out the taste, then cool it and add plenty of vinegar to keep them crisp. This method just doesn't deliver.

Mariana Klemm
Reviews 1

I gave the Amanda's Cookin' bread recipe a try, though it was quite the challenge! The dough is seriously high-hydration; I had to dump in the full amount of flour from the instructions plus another cup just to keep my hands on it. Even after the first rise, it remained incredibly sticky, forcing me to knead in even more flour to get it manageable. The loaves ended up flattening out significantly during the second rise—my husband jokingly dubbed it "Manatee bread." Despite the messy process and odd shape, the final result tasted great. I think the issue is just that two cups of water is a bit too much for the flour ratio. I’ll definitely attempt it again in the future.

Cathy
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' really nailed it with these cookies. I followed the recipe but added a granulated white sugar coating before flattening them out, and the result was incredibly tender. I'm completely converted; I think I'm done with the original peanut butter variety and will stick with the chocolate ones from now on.

Lori
Reviews 1

I gave Amanda's Cookin' recipe a slight twist today! I swapped in brown sugar and almond extract, then baked it in a jelly roll pan at 350 for about 20 minutes. Finished it off with cream cheese frosting, and it turned out even better than a standard pumpkin bar. Thanks for the inspiration—I hope you don't mind the tweaks. I might just have to grab another slice right now!

Dee Mitch
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' really nailed it with this bake ziti! It’s incredibly easy to make, and I tweaked it slightly by swapping in diced tomatoes since I’m not a fan of big chunks, plus a can of Rotel for that extra kick. I served it to a small group, and the result was so good that three different people actually asked for the recipe.

Aubrey Dean Goins
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' really knows how to make the most of imperfect fruit. I’ve baked this cantaloupe bread three times already and I’m mid-way through my fourth batch. It’s honestly too delicious to share; I’ve mostly consumed the loaves on my own. Even the one I stashed in the freezer gets devoured almost as soon as I thaw it out to start on the next slice.

Vaughn Slavin
Reviews 1

I really appreciate the recipe from Amanda's Cookin'! I made it with the extra lemons I had on hand, and the result was excellent. I stored half in the fridge and noticed a nice little fizz, which tells me the fermentation is working perfectly. I actually have another batch in a gallon jar right now. The salt and vinegar balance is just right. I used coarse sea salt and standard white vinegar, making small adjustments as needed. The top stayed clear with no scum, and if only I had more fridge space to preserve them all!

Lucy
Reviews 1

Thanks for the recipe, Amanda! I skipped greasing the slow cooker by lining it with parchment paper, which made cleanup a breeze. The result wasn’t super pretty in the pan—probably because my pot was bigger than yours—but it tasted amazing. I ended up with a thick layer of custard on top since I managed to soak up all the liquid through the holes. Letting it chill overnight really helped, giving it that classic tres leches vibe. Great dish from Amanda's Cookin'!

Susan
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' has become my go-to spot for dessert. I love that their chocolate creations are rich and satisfying without being overly sweet—they really do taste just like a chocolate Eclair. Plus, the quality is consistently great, making it easy to keep coming back for more.

Katica
Reviews 1

I used Amanda's Cookin' recipe to bake a banana split cake with chocolate and vanilla layers. Since the base recipe yields enough batter for two 8-inch rounds, I simply doubled it using both flavors. The only tweak I made was adding a bit of flour to account for the smaller size of modern box mixes (usually around 15.25 oz). The result was perfect—both layers turned out beautiful and delicious.

Pearl
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' recipes are great, but pay attention to the details. I usually let my marinade sit overnight and toss the pieces every 15 minutes. Skip that step like I did the first time, and you’ll end up with brown sugar that hardens into candy after 40 minutes in the oven.

Alison
Reviews 1

I followed the Amanda's Cookin' recipe to the letter and the results were fantastic. My husband was thrilled, noting that they taste exactly like Reese’s Cup cookies. Since I baked them on an insulated sheet, I had to extend the cooking time to 12 minutes, but the outcome was worth it. These have quickly become a new favorite in our household!

Elizabeth Lees
Reviews 1

This mac and cheese recipe from Amanda's Cookin' is truly a standout dish, and it’s so simple to prepare. I had a minor hiccup—I should have made sure the pasta water was boiling before starting the cheese sauce—but it wasn’t a dealbreaker. My 20-year-old grandson declared it the best, which is high praise! I’ve even added thawed frozen vegetables, and my husband loves stirring in cooked chicken. It’s definitely a staple in our kitchen. I also want to say that I always turn to the amandascookin.com website first for recipes. Whether I’m looking for dinner ideas, desserts, or muffins, I’ve consistently found great results there. Thank you!

Dawn
Reviews 1

We had a blast with Amanda's Cookin! We tweaked the recipe a bit to suit our tastes: we doubled the batch, cut back on the powdered sugar to just a quarter cup so it wasn't too sweet, and swapped the almond extract for vanilla yogurt plus some Cool Whip since we were out. The result was absolutely delicious, lightly sweetened and the perfect complement to the fruit.

Alana
Reviews 1

I just whipped up a batch from Amanda's Cookin' and they turned out amazing! I initially hesitated to add enough plums because I was worried about them getting too soggy, but after tasting the result, I’m definitely going to load them up next time without holding back.

Jimylu
Reviews 1

The flavors at Amanda's Cookin' were spot on. I decided to customize my bowl with a bit of fresh corn and some roasted Hatch peppers, which turned out to be a perfect match. My dining partner and I both thoroughly enjoyed the meal. It’s clear they put real care into their recipes.

Kat
Reviews 1

I tried Amanda's Cookin' veggie pizza recipe today and it was a total success! Adding a generous teaspoon of chopped garlic to the onion and chive cream cheese base really elevated the flavor. I baked an extra-large size, and it went down a treat at dinner. The guests loved it so much they polished off the whole thing and demanded the recipe—I should have made two!

LaVaDu
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' delivered a solid Mexican meal that was easy to customize. I enhanced the broth with chili powder, Cholula, cumin, and corn, then topped it with fresh homegrown tomatoes, sour cream, and tortilla chips. The portion size is generous, ensuring plenty for leftovers.

Deb
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' has been a lifesaver for my diabetic husband. I adapted one of their recipes to be mostly keto, swapping in sugar-free lemon jello pudding, lemon cream cheese with monkfruit, and sugar-free Cool Whip. I kept the original crust since finding a flour substitute that actually tastes good is tough. The result was delicious!

Molly S
Reviews 1

Loved the dish from Amanda's Cookin'! The flavor profile is spot on. I did notice a small typo in the ingredient list where it says "2 ounces shredded Mexican 4 cheese blend" instead of cream cheese, but the directions clarified that you add 2 ounces of cream cheese once melted, so I had no trouble figuring it out. It would be helpful to update the list, but the recipe itself is delicious!

Pam Graydon
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' really nailed it with this recipe. It has quickly become a weekly staple in our house and is always a crowd-pleaser. My husband loves it so much that he always exclaims "OMG I love this!" after the first bite. I made a few adjustments to bulk it up—using a full cup of red pepper and upping the beef to 1 1/2 lbs while reducing the macaroni to just one cup—but the core flavors remain fantastic. The spice blend is incredible, especially the Magic Dust.

CLAIRE MOYNIHAN
Reviews 1

I was really impressed with the quality from Amanda's Cookin'. The dish came out perfectly cooked. Since my roast was on the smaller side, I kept a close eye on it with a meat thermometer to make sure it didn't dry out, and it worked perfectly. I especially loved the sweet, caramelized vegetable topping—it added a wonderful touch to the meal.

Lisa Dietrich
Reviews 1

I’ve been eyeing the cream cheese filling from Amanda's Cookin' and it looks fantastic, though I haven’t baked it yet since it’s still chilling in the fridge. I have a bit of a sweet tooth, so when I accidentally tossed the whole 8-ounce block of cream cheese into my 8x8 pan, the result was still delightfully rich and sweet. It took some careful patting of the graham cracker topping to squeeze everything in, but I’m really hoping the family loves it as much as I do.

Alissa
Reviews 1

I’ve baked this cake countless times at Amanda's Cookin', experimenting with various mix and pudding combinations. While the lemon version was a crowd-pleaser, the pistachio remains my top choice. I’m currently trying it with chocolate and can’t wait to see how it turns out! This recipe has truly become a household staple thanks to how simple and reliable it is.

Teresa O'malley
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' has earned a permanent spot in my heart after I tried this dessert. It completely dethroned the pineapple upside down cake that used to be my husband's top choice. He was thrilled with the result! Huge thanks to Amanda for the recipe; this is definitely going to be a regular in my kitchen.

Stacey
Reviews 1

The donuts at Amanda's Cookin' tasted great, but I had a bit of a mix-up with the baking instructions. Since they didn't specify how much batter to use, I filled the wells all the way to the top, which resulted in a dome shape more like cupcakes. I ended up having to slice off the tops to make them look right.

Barbara OHara
Reviews 1

Hi Amanda's Cookin' team! I’m reaching out for some recipe inspiration from my home base in the office kitchen. For the past seven years, I’ve been baking for a group of about sixty people every month at the doctor’s office. I absolutely adore your recipes, but I’m looking for a change of pace. I’m considering using one of your cakes as a topping for gingerbread to skip the graham cracker crumbs, since I find gingerbread tends to be a bit dry. Do you think that pairing would work well? At 82, I’m on the hunt for new ideas that are simple to make but still look impressive. Any advice would be greatly appreciated!

Susan Seeger
Reviews 1

I’ve baked from Amanda's Cookin' a few times now and the dough is consistently reliable. The flavor is spot on, and the texture works perfectly for piping. I usually skip the cinnamon for one grandkid, but the base taste holds up. I’ve experimented with a chocolate glaze and a dusting of powdered sugar, both of which are great. Out of all the baked goods I’ve tried, this is by far my favorite. I even recommend a quick stint under the broiler at the very end to get a lovely golden color on top.

Sherry Greenwood
Reviews 1

I baked the Amanda's Cookin' cake and it turned out wonderfully moist and airy, quite different from typical banana bread. Although the crust browned a bit more than expected, it didn't affect the overall quality. Since my bananas were quite starchy, I added three heaping tablespoons of brown sugar to the mix, which really enhanced the flavor. The final result was delicious, and I’m definitely going to make it again. I finished it off with a whipped chocolate ganache.

Michael
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' has truly made me a convert. I never thought I could turn this affordable, lean cut into such a tender and flavorful meal. It was surprisingly simple to prepare, breaking my habit of avoiding tougher meats. This recipe easily earns its five-star rating.

Amy Boak
Reviews 1

Amanda's Cookin' made this recipe accessible even for a beginner like me. I was initially worried it would be too complex to follow from a book alone, but it turned out to be very straightforward. The entire family loved the meal, and it even earned high praise from my mother-in-law, who is a dietitian. It was truly delicious, just make sure to stick to the instructions.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Amanda's Cookin'