Login or sign up
For business

Affinity insurance group

4.8· 33 reviews
Average ratingExcellent
4.8/ 5

Based on 33 reviews

582%
418%
30%
20%
10%
Ask AI

Questions about Affinity insurance group

Based on 33 reviews, listing data and website checks · updated 4 days ago

What is Affinity insurance group?

Affinity Insurance Group is a family-owned independent insurance agency located in Apex, North Carolina, at 800 W Williams St, Ste 231H. They specialize in providing auto, home, business, umbrella, and life insurance to individuals, families, and businesses across North Carolina, including areas like Cary, Holly Springs, and Raleigh.

How does their independent agency model differ from other providers?

The agency operates as a Trusted Choice Independent Insurance Agency, meaning they do not work for a single carrier but instead select from multiple financially strong insurance companies to find the best coverage and competitive pricing for their clients' specific lifestyles and needs.

What are the requirements for getting a new quote?

For new clients requesting a home quote, the agency requires that auto insurance be included in the bundle. They offer various policy types including homeowners, auto, business, and life insurance, with options for bundling home and auto together.

How can I contact Affinity Insurance Group?

Clients can contact the agency by phone at (919) 296-3787 or via text message to 919.823.7885. The text line is available exclusively for clients, and first-time users must include their name or business in the message to identify their mobile number.

Who is this agency suitable for?

The agency serves a wide range of demographics, including individuals and families, retired people, single adults, married couples with or without children, high-net-worth individuals, empty nesters, and college students.

What do reviewers say about their service?

Reviewers consistently praise Mike Petilli and his team for exceptional service, responsiveness, and genuine care. Many clients highlight how the team helped them cut costs on home and auto policies while maintaining quality, and noted their quick response times during claims and relocations.

Are there any current pricing trends or rate changes?

As of June 1, 2025, the average statewide homeowner's insurance premium in North Carolina increased by 7.5%, with coastal areas seeing higher increases up to 16% due to hurricane risks. The agency notes that these changes affect all clients regardless of claim history.

What digital tools are available for existing clients?

The agency's website features a client portal for online billing and payments, as well as tools to file claims, request certificates of insurance, and make policy change requests.

Who are the key people on the team?

The team includes Agency Principal Mike Petilli, Agency Partners JoAnn Petilli and Michael Petilli, Executive Assistant Danielle Petilli, Personal Lines Agents Inie Park and Sarah Kocor, and Customer Service Representative John Castillo.

How long has the agency been operating?

The agency has been serving the community for over 20 years, with team members who have lived in North Carolina for that duration. They emphasize building long-lasting relationships and being neighbors to their clients.

What specialized insurance options do they offer?

The agency offers specialized coverage for unique situations, including motorcycle and boat & marine insurance, as well as business-specific options like commercial auto, commercial property, general liability, and workers' compensation.

What additional resources are available to clients?

Clients can utilize the secure contact form on the website to reach the Apex office, and the agency provides resources such as a referral program and a blog called 'Get a Clue'.

How do they handle claims and losses?

The agency emphasizes that they work on the client's side during a loss to ensure fair, prompt payment and service, rather than just processing paperwork.

What are their operating hours?

The agency operates on a Mon-Fri schedule from 8:30 am to 5:00 pm, with closed hours on Saturdays and Sundays.

Where is Affinity insurance group located?

Affinity insurance group is located at 800 W Williams St, Ste 231H, Apex, North Carolina.

AI-generated from reviews on this page. Verify anything important with the company directly.

Brett H.
Reviews 1

Switching from a major provider after two decades was the smartest move we made. Mike Petilli and the team at Affinity Insurance Group in Apex truly delivered exceptional service. They helped us cut costs on both our home and auto insurance without compromising on quality. If you are looking for top-notch support, this is the place to go.

Jeff H.
Reviews 1

We’ve relied on Affinity Insurance Group in Apex for all our family’s coverage needs, including home, auto, and umbrella policies. Mike and his son Michael have consistently gone above and beyond. Their response times are quick, and they are incredibly supportive. Whether it was helping us after my son’s car accident, assisting with the relocation of our elderly parents-in-law to North Carolina, or handling our hurricane damage claim, they were there every step of the way. It’s easy to take a dependable insurer for granted until an issue arises, but Affinity truly stands out. I’m giving them five stars and highly recommend them. Thank you, Mike and Michael!

Whitney H.
Reviews 1

Mike Petilli is a true professional at Affinity Insurance Group in Apex. He helped me cut over four thousand dollars annually on both my home and auto policies. The transition was incredibly smooth and hassle-free. I can’t recommend Mike enough for his dedication and results.

- J.
Reviews 1

Affinity Insurance Group in Apex truly stands out for their responsiveness and genuine care for their clients. The team at this insurance agency goes above and beyond to secure competitive rates, delivering an exceptional customer experience that makes them a top choice for anyone looking for reliable coverage.

Jason L.
Reviews 1

Mike has handled my insurance needs for a decade, and I can confidently say he’s the best agent in the Apex area. His service is exceptional. I’m staying with Affinity Insurance Group for the long haul and highly recommend them to anyone looking for reliable coverage.

Bryan C.
Reviews 1

Affinity Insurance Group in Apex came through with an outstanding homeowners policy. Mike Petilli provided the most competitive rate I found and made the entire experience seamless. He was incredibly responsive, ensuring all my questions were answered quickly and thoroughly.

David C.
Reviews 1

I’ve been with Mike at Affinity Insurance Group in Apex for years and couldn’t be happier. He treats me and my wife with genuine care, and everyone I refer to him gets that same high level of service. It’s impressive that he even made time to help my nephew on a holiday weekend!

Colleen G.
Reviews 1

Working with Mike Petilli at Affinity Insurance Group in Apex is a refreshing experience. He cuts right to the chase and gives you honest answers without any fluff. If you need an agent who truly knows their stuff and ensures you have the right coverage, these are the people to call. Highly recommended for anyone looking for reliable guidance on their insurance needs.

BL S.
Reviews 1

I’ve been working with Mike Petilli at Affinity Insurance Group for years, and he continues to impress. He really knows his stuff and is always quick to jump in and help when I have questions. He handles all my personal and business policies, and the service is top-notch. I still remember when I filed my first home insurance claim back in 2019; Mike made the whole process smooth and got it sorted out fast. If you are looking for an agent in Apex, NC, I can’t recommend him enough. He is simply the best.

Jennifer T.
Reviews 1

I’ve had the privilege of working with Mike and the team at Affinity Insurance in Apex for several years now. Unlike previous experiences where I felt like just another policy number, here I’ve built a genuine personal connection. It is incredibly reassuring to know I can call them directly and speak with someone who truly knows my history and needs. It’s refreshing to support a family-owned agency in North Carolina that genuinely invests in its clients rather than just processing paperwork. I can confidently recommend them to anyone looking for a more personal touch in their insurance coverage.

Ann M.
Reviews 1

I am thoroughly impressed with Affinity Insurance Group and especially with JoAnn Petilli. She went above and beyond my expectations, not only by securing a lower premium for me but also by providing my quotes with incredible speed. JoAnn built my trust through her thorough questioning and her deep expertise in explaining every aspect of my vehicle coverage options. I would describe her as highly professional, detail-oriented, and a true expert. If I ever need to file a claim, I am confident she will handle it with the same level of care and advocacy she showed when onboarding me. I highly recommend JoAnn and the entire team at Affinity Insurance Group.

Madeline H.
Reviews 1

Mike at Affinity Insurance Group in Apex really went the extra mile to secure a policy that fit my budget without skimping on coverage. The team was warm and professional throughout the process. It is hands down the best agency around for all your insurance needs.

Kurt Krebs
Reviews 1

I recently switched my insurance to Affinity Insurance Group and I am extremely satisfied with their services. The rates they offered were competitive and the coverage options were comprehensive. The agents were professional and efficient, making the whole process quick and easy. I appreciate their attention to detail and the personalized approach they take with their clients. I highly recommend Affinity Insurance Group!

Prashant Sharma
Reviews 1

I recently switched to Affinity Insurance Group and I couldn't be happier with my decision. The agents were knowledgeable and helped me choose the right coverage for my needs. The rates they offered were competitive and the customer service was outstanding. I highly recommend Affinity Insurance Group for anyone looking for reliable insurance!

Dominic Doctor
Reviews 1

I recently became a customer of Affinity Insurance Group and I am incredibly impressed with their services. The agents are professional and knowledgeable, and they made the whole process of getting insurance easy and hassle-free. The rates they offered were competitive and the coverage options were comprehensive. I highly recommend Affinity Insurance Group!

Brian Beach
Reviews 1

I have been a customer of Affinity Insurance Group for a few years now and I am extremely satisfied with their services. The agents are friendly and knowledgeable, and they always make sure to find the best coverage options for me. I have never had any issues with claims or billing, and their rates are competitive. I highly recommend Affinity Insurance Group for your insurance needs!

Sean Henaghan
Reviews 1

Affinity Insurance Group is the best insurance company I have ever dealt with. The agents are friendly, helpful, and always go above and beyond to ensure their clients are satisfied. The claims process is efficient and hassle-free. I highly recommend Affinity Insurance Group for all your insurance needs!

Casandra Olson
Reviews 1

Affinity Insurance Group has been my insurance provider for many years and I am completely satisfied with their services. The agents are professional and knowledgeable, and they always provide prompt assistance whenever I need it. I have had to file a claim in the past and they handled it efficiently and effectively. I highly recommend Affinity Insurance Group for all your insurance needs!

Matthew Headlee
Reviews 1

Affinity Insurance Group is simply the best insurance company out there. The agents are always there to assist and answer any questions I may have. The rates are affordable and the coverage options are comprehensive. I have been a satisfied customer for years and I highly recommend Affinity Insurance Group to anyone in need of insurance!

Dennis Dumas
Reviews 1

Affinity Insurance Group has been providing me with excellent insurance coverage for many years. The agents are professional, courteous, and always willing to help. I appreciate their attention to detail and their prompt response to any inquiries I may have. I highly recommend Affinity Insurance Group for all your insurance needs!

Doug Chapman
Reviews 1

I recently switched my insurance to a new provider and I am extremely happy with Affinity Insurance Group. The rates they offered were affordable and the coverage options were exactly what I needed. The agents were helpful and made the whole process easy. I feel confident that I am in good hands with Affinity Insurance Group.

Wayne R
Reviews 1

❤️ I am so impressed with Affinity Insurance Group! Their customer service is outstanding and the agents are always ready to assist me with any concerns or questions. They truly care about their clients and it shows in the quality of their services. I recently had to file a claim and they made the process incredibly smooth. I highly recommend Affinity Insurance Group to anyone in need of insurance. ❤️

Kathy W.
Reviews 1

Affinity Insurance Group has been my go-to insurance provider for a decade, and Mike P. and his team truly put the customer first. Whenever I have a question, whether it’s figuring out how hail damage affects my premiums or planning for my daughter starting to drive, they walk me through the options with genuine expertise and care. It’s refreshing to find an agency that combines this level of personal attention with honest integrity. I wish more companies operated with this kind of dedication. I’m incredibly grateful for their support and highly recommend them. Kathy W.

Richard Felicione
Reviews 1

👍 I can't say enough good things about Affinity Insurance Group! Their customer service is top-notch and the agents are always friendly and helpful. They go above and beyond to ensure that their clients are well taken care of. I recently had to make a claim and they made the process so simple and stress-free. I highly recommend Affinity Insurance Group to anyone looking for reliable and trustworthy insurance coverage. 👍

Terrance Judge
Reviews 1

I have been a customer of Affinity Insurance Group for several years now and I have always been impressed with their exceptional service. The agents are friendly and knowledgeable, and they always take the time to answer any questions I have. I have had to file a couple of claims over the years and each time, the process has been smooth and hassle-free. I highly recommend Affinity Insurance Group to anyone in need of insurance!

Obaid Mohammad
Reviews 1

👌 Affinity Insurance Group is my go-to insurance provider! The agents are always helpful and they make the whole process easy and stress-free. I recently had to file a claim and they handled it quickly and efficiently. I feel confident that I made the right choice choosing Affinity Insurance Group and I highly recommend them to anyone in need of insurance. 👌

Maria G.
Reviews 1

Having worked with Mike Petilli for more than a year, I’ve been consistently impressed with his service. He takes the time to understand my specific needs and is always quick to assist with any inquiries. My experience with Affinity Insurance Group has been excellent, and I highly recommend him to anyone in Apex looking for reliable insurance support.

Richard C.
Reviews 1

Mike has been an exceptional partner for both my personal and business coverage over the last four years. At Affinity Insurance Group in Apex, his reliability really stands out, especially when you actually need support during a claim. It is rare to find someone who is not only trustworthy but genuinely helpful when things go wrong.

News

No news yet. This is where the business shares its own updates and press.

Photos

No photos yet. Photos shared by reviewers will show up here.

Widgets

Boost your business trust by displaying a widget on your website — a simple way to convert your visitors into customers.

Get the widget for your site →

About Affinity insurance group

Address
800 W Williams St, Ste 231H
Categories
Insurance