Arbuckles Eatery and Pub Reviews

This restaurant is hit or miss. It's either really good or a flop. The waitstaff is good but sometimes the food isn't.

You have to check this place out and try the cheese fries there to die for.

Italian fries are great! Always very clean, and they have friendly service. Alot of beer choices also.

NOMS! miss the Cheese Fries.

service isnt the best sometimes, but they get busy, and its worth the wait for the cheese fries! and their ranch is DELICIOUS!

The Italian Fries with cheese and Jambalaya are awesome!

Food is delicious and the wait isn t that bad. The owner was very crabby and definitely left a bad outcome on our thoughts of Arbuckles.

Only went here because nothing else was open on Labor Day. The pizza was very underbaked so we sent it back. Came back still underbaked. Way too much cheese. Crust was dry and flavorless definitely frozen and not homemade. I ve had better pizza from the grocery store. Service is average. We sat outside. Loud buzzing noises. Smells good so maybe I got the wrong menu item but probably won t come back to find out.

Our food was very good. Italian sausage in pizza a little to spicy. Our waitress wasn't very friendly.

Food served cold. Server brought out a few dinners and the rest took 14 minutes to bring out. Some were already done eating by the time food was completely served. They only had four other tables full while we were there. Owner was very rude and had a terrible attitude when we shared our complaint. The cook even walked by staring at us to see what the complaint was all about. The only person who apologized was server which was a very nice lady. Owner only said I can get you a gift card for next time. No thanks!

We had the pizza, takeout. I highly recommend it. They were shy with the toppings, but everything tasted great.

Great food at reasonable prices. Attentive and friendly waitstaff.

Great Italian fries! My parents swear they re the best in central Wisconsin!

Great beer and food. Patio is wonderful in the summer!

Very good , excellent food, service little slow but they were busy

Nice outdoor seating. Good food and friendly staff.

Got to love the cheese fries and the pesto chicken wrap.

Excellent food & service! Love the Italian Fries!!!

Awesome pizza fries awesome pizza tons of cheese next time probably order well done just so I can get that brown crusty cheese. Still five stars

Love this place. We bring the family often and get Italian Cheese Fries they are the best around in my opinion. People are great and the place is clean.

Nice place to meet friends for lunch. I was pleasantly surprised at their Black and Blue salad. Most pubs in Wisconsin do not have good salads. My wife also liked her hamburger. I look forward to returning!

The food here as good but the service was a little bit slow and my friend didn't get what he ordered. But I mean otherwise, good, I guess?

Excellent burgers, mac and cheese, and Friday fish fry.

We were most interested in a quick meal. Being out of towners, I found that this place kept showing up in my searches for a good place to eat. Pictures of Italian fries caught my attention. They were delicious without a doubt! My husband also had the chili. That was delicious and warm. I had the clam chowder. It was cold and just nothing to write home about. Everyone was friendly. While the restaurant was cute, more tables and fewer booths would have been nice. I don't like them and my husband hates them. People with soecial needs or large groups don't fit them either.

Pizza has WAAAAAAAAAAAAAY too much cheese on it and not enough sauce.

Love Arbuckles! The pizza to the French onion soup and the staff are great!

Decent cafe. A bit too much grease, but otherwise nice and simple food. Wide selection of beers, mostly national brands but a few interesting local brews.

Good, but server blew off chunk of aluminum foil we found embedded in the middle of our cheese fries.
On a good note we were not charged for the extra foil.

Food was good, environment was great. Cheese curds needed improvement.

Beer battered shrimp. Not quite the best in town, but pretty close.

Sooooo good! Not a big fan of their new hours, but the food is sooooo good! The Italian Fries with Cheese are a must! The soups are great too! Fish Fries, Sandwhiches, and Wraps are to die for! Dessert could be better, other than that everything is amazing!

Food was ok, waitress was not that great, didnt take our plates after we were done eating, that's a serious no no.

Food was great, service was great, price was right!

Good service and food. Environment was nice and welcoming. The signature Italian fries were worth it but the pizza left me with a taste of bland and greasy. Is certainly worth a visit with the family or friends for a wholesome bite to eat.

Wonderful place to enjoy a meal. Survice was astounding thanks to their waitress Tessa. The food was perfect deff recommend Baja burger for those that like burgers

They have lost my business for good. I last went here a couple of weeks ago. There were several waitresses milling around talking to each other. I waited at the hostess station for 5 to 10 minutes and none of them took notice of myself or my friend that was with me. So we seated ourselves and we were then told, quite rudely, that we should have waited at the hostess station. We then were ignored for another 10 or 15 minutes. And today was the final straw, I received a phone call from my grandparents stating they were turned away because there was no handicapped seating available, and when my grandparents inquired as to what they should do the hostess told them simply "You should have called instead of just showing up." This is absolutely UNACCEPTABLE. We have frequented this business for over TEN years, so to be treated so poorly and so rudely was completely despicable. They have lost our business for good. Anyone that can so cold and callous to, not only the ELDERLY, but to the HANDICAPPED does not deserve to have their business frequented. Hopefully they're satisfied with their service, because we aren't.

Italian fries with cheese! Best in town! Great staff and nice clean location. Great place to hangout and watch the game.

Cheese Fries, need I say more. Wish they had more sour beers on their list.

Amazing food, atmosphere and personnel. Check it out Monday thru Saturday 11 a.m. till 9 p.m. dine in or carry out.

Great Experience. Patio is very nice in summertime and the cheese fries are phenomenal.

Wasnt terribly impressed. Ordered a bacon cheese burger medium rare, onion rings and a cup of chili and a Coors light (since they dont have Bud light). The chili was decent. They were out of onion rings ( on a Saturday night) the burger came almost well done, no color at all, the bacon was obviously old, very dry, crumbly and the fat was yelllow, and the skin on the pickle spear that came with it was so dry, I had to try to peel the pickle off the skin. I dont send food back, I dont wanna chance getting someone's DNA on it, but I was very tempted. Not sure I'd eat there again....

Average bar and burgers. About $9 for burger and fries which isn't bad but they're pretty average. I really wanted them to stand out. They do offer gluten free/lettuce wraps. Their sweet potato fries are good. The baha burger is very mild. Everything is very toned down in flavor "safe" bar food.

Italian fries for days! Decent burgers, sandwiches, and wraps, too.

As everyone has been saying, the cheese fries are amazing and I feel like they're a great deal. One of the cheesiest items I've ever had by far. Besides this, I felt that their wing prices were much cheaper than other similar locations. Beer selection is great and overall I think that there is a food here for everyone as they serve a large variety at also varying prices.

The burgers were undercooked, half our order was forgotten, the portions were small, and no matter how much we asked and repeated ourselves the server forgot just about everything. Honestly wish I could rate zero...

I love this place, always go with cheese frys, and don't forget extra sauce!

Great food and great service! Definitely try the Italian fries with cheese!

If u don't try the Italian cheese fries at least once in ur life.... Idk what kind of life ur living... Lol

Excellent local pub-style food and drinks. Great beer selection, you can even do the marathon of beer. Food is excellent for its class.

Got Italian fries for the first time in a long time and they were as delicious as always!!

Great food, great staff, quiet setting. Nice family place to eat.

Great atmosphere, amazing service, food is always good and you can't go wrong with the marathon of beers! It's definitely a good place to become a regular.

Amazing mozzarella fries! So ooye gooey cheesy deliciousness. Very large portions. Pizza is definitely a winner here! So much food and so many leftovers.

Not impressed. Ordered the salad which was not better than anything I could have made myself.
Server was friendly.
The bathrooms were a mess, the stall doors coming off the wall and in one place was held together by duct tape. The menus were very empty, with just a few items for each type of food. Felt very sketchy and not well put together. You would think that after 30 years they would have figured out how to run a restaurant but I guess not.

Love this place! Staff is amazing and cheese fries and pizza is awesome

Awesome food, I would recommend the Monterey chicken sandwich! Service is always nice.

This place has a wide variety of food, including daily specials. The best thing on the menu is Italian cheese fries, although they do take a while to get them (20 mins minimum). One huge draw to this place is the "Marathon of Beers". It's a punch card of 27 different beers, from Old Style to IPA's to Stouts. The selections do change from time to time. Whether new to the area or a lifelong resident, Arbuckles is a great place to eat.