Chuck Paschall

Review of O'Toole's Restaurant & Pub

First time, menu seems very big. Got a patty melt ...

First time, menu seems very big. Got a patty melt and asked for it medium well. Came bloody and cold in the middle. Waiter corrected it by taking my plate back to kitchen. Mind you I already took two bites out of it. They brought it back, same sandwich, somehow greasier. Did they put my partially eaten sandwich back on the grill?! Yes they did. How often does this happen? On top of that it was just oily and needed salt. Service was fine and drink prices are ok (but they aren t pints). Appetizers I got were fair for just fried stuff.