I wish this could be 5 stars (which has totally th...

I wish this could be 5 stars (which has totally the potential to earn them) but the non-consistency with the quality of food and poor service makes this place 2 stars for now.

The first night my wife and I had dinner here, we had an overall great experience. The food was good (we ordered rib eye steak and fresh branzino) and the atmosphere makes this place magical. They forgot our drinks but the server made up for it and comped them at the end which was very nice of him.

However, the second night we went we felt pretty much ignored the whole time and they totally forgot that we were there. They brought us bread half an hour after we set down and the food wasn t great at all.

We ordered shrimps and they came after a while cold - we told them that the dish was cold and they brought it back completely dry, burned and inedible. I then ordered conch burger which wasn t good either.

The morning after we gave this place another chance with breakfast and turned out to be also disappointing in terms of food quality.

Considering that this island is quite pricey, I would expect at least good service and consistency in the quality of food.

It seems that the winning dishes at this place are their daily specials and main courses. Anything else is quite bland.

If they improve the highlighted points I m sure that this can be one of the best restaurants on the island.