My wife and I decided to trust Lulu's with our gen...

My wife and I decided to trust Lulu's with our gender-reveal cake for her baby shower... what a big mistake!! When I went to pick up the cake the morning of the baby shower, the staff had left a sticker on the cake box - A BLUE STICKER clearly revealing the baby's gender when we obviously wanted to keep it a secret.

You had ONE job!! :( They completely ruined my surprise and you would think that a bakery who prides themselves on providing such cakes would be more sensible!!

We ordered the chocolate cake, and overall the taste was very disappointing. It tasted like something you'd get from Stop & Shop or Costco, definitely not rich, creamy, and decadent as you would expect from a good bakery; especially considering their prices!

I'm giving two stars because the appearance of the cake was amazing and exactly how we requested it - they definitely nailed this part!

I would not trust Lulu's for a gender reveal cake and would be very cautious about choosing the cake type!!