Sal's Pizza

4.5 · 137 reviews
R
Roderick L
Reviews 1
2020-09-25 06:00

First time visiting and picking up pizza at this l...

First time visiting and picking up pizza at this location.
Pretty far from where we live but thought we'd give it a try.
We ordered the Garbage pizza, thin crust. It has all the ingredients I love.
We liked it.
Do we go back and order from them again? Maybe if we're around the area.
From where ...

Read full review

A
Alexis Williams
Reviews 1
2020-09-13 09:30

Hands down one of my favorite pizza places in the ...

Hands down one of my favorite pizza places in the area. Note that they do not having a dining room - so take out only. But their pizza is delicious! I am a big fan of their thin crust spinach and cheese pizza. The pizza is consistent, HOT (temp wise) and they use plenty of cheese! They also offer c...

Read full review

K
Kevin Shryock
Reviews 1
2020-09-07 23:23

You should be ashamed to be serving the community....

You should be ashamed to be serving the community.

I couldn't have predicted that there'd be a restaurant with NOT A SINGLE EMPLOYEE WEARING A MASK in this time of COVID-19. I'm not even talking about improper mask wearing. 10 out of 10 employees, working in the kitchen had not a bit of PPE. Besi...

Read full review

E
Esme T
Reviews 1
2020-08-26 23:08

We catered from Sal's for our baby shower. The del...

We catered from Sal's for our baby shower. The delivery showed up right on time and the driver did all of the setting up. Food arrived hot and stayed hot for hours. Before he left he made sure to explain the set up. The food was amazing and everyone loved it. First time ordering from Sal's and defin...

Read full review

J
Jake Garcia
Reviews 1
2020-08-14 12:16

It's one of those hole in the wall places your iff...

It's one of those hole in the wall places your iffy to try but man am I so glad that I have will never order thin crust pizza from anywhere but Sal's. The flavor and freshness of the ingredients cooked to perfection in a pizza pie! Highly recommend Sal's

Read full review

R
Rob Greco
Reviews 1
2020-08-10 17:27

Dissapointing. Ingredients are not fresh. I ordere...

Dissapointing. Ingredients are not fresh. I ordered a pizza with mushrooms and tomatoes, both of which obviously came out of a can - as far from fresh as vegetables can get. Sauce was a bit lacking in flavor as well. Quantity of toppings was good but does not make up for sub-par pizza. Best of lu...

Read full review

C
Christopher Flick
Reviews 1
2020-08-07 23:32

Pizza is great here, they tend to the well done si...

Pizza is great here, they tend to the well done side of cooking the pizzas so keep that in mind when ordering or once you receive yours. The pastas and sides are good but the star of the show is the pizza. Delivery is pretty quick and the staff seem like good kids, owners are good people and always ...

Read full review

R
Robyn Condon
Reviews 1
2020-08-02 00:52

My family has been ordering from Sal's Pizza for m...

My family has been ordering from Sal's Pizza for many years. The pizza is always EXCELLENT and of the highest quality. One day I had a taste for something a little different and I dared to try tried the ribs. I love ribs, I admit it. I was a little nervous about it as pizza places typically aren...

Read full review

K
Kyle Bartels
Reviews 1
2020-07-19 12:27

Mmm mmm mmmmmmm. This is the best pizza place arou...

Mmm mmm mmmmmmm. This is the best pizza place around. Since moving here 5 1/2 years ago, we had to of tried all of the pizza places around here. Not being big on "chains" we were looking for that local place. Had driven by many many times, and never thought to give the place behind the 7-11 a try. H...

Read full review

M
max can
Reviews 1
2020-07-13 13:21

The driver brought us 2 pizzas that were meant for...

The driver brought us 2 pizzas that were meant for someone else. I understand that mistakes happen and we would've been fine waiting another hour for the correct pizzas. The discussion was getting uncomfortable and the driver kept insisting that we accept the wrong pizza. It's really unfortunate t...

Read full review

L
Luke Romin
Reviews 1
2020-07-05 21:09

Love Sals pizza and the beefs! Always a good meal ...

Love Sals pizza and the beefs! Always a good meal and a hit at parties. Only complaint is what the bacon on the pizza has become. It used to be good size cuts/chunks. Now it s just some tiny sprinkles... definitely should switch back for that bit of difference

Read full review

M
Michael Webb
Reviews 1
2020-07-05 19:04

Thin crust cheese pizza "pie cut"!!! Just like my ...

Thin crust cheese pizza "pie cut"!!! Just like my Poppa's restaurant used to make from the 1950's to the 80s. Absolutely perfect. Thank you so much to ALL the great crew who worked tirelessly through this blizzard of wind, rain and snow so my family and I could enjoy a delicious Sal's Pizza.

Read full review

R
Robert Wise
Reviews 1
2020-07-02 09:03

I grew up in this area, and I make it a point to s...

I grew up in this area, and I make it a point to stop and pick up a sal's pizza anytime I'm in the area. I love their pizza, but I have to admit the prices are a little steep for a thin crust takeout pizza, which is the only reason i did not give 5 stars, but worth it if you feel like splurging.

Read full review

S
Sheri Lathrop
Reviews 1
2020-07-02 04:41

Toppings are right amount. Not over abundant not u...

Toppings are right amount. Not over abundant not under abundant . All are fresh with the exception of canned mushrooms and tomatoes. And like everyone else that makes pizza in Algonquin you just have to tell them how thick you want your cardboard crust. None of us were able to eat the crust. Ended u...

Read full review

B
Budman s Corner
Reviews 1
2020-06-21 21:55

So I have been ordering from Sal's fro a while. F...

So I have been ordering from Sal's fro a while. For the most part they were great. You get a 18 in pizza and you can barely carry the thing. Not the case tonight. I ordered and 18 in sausage and mushroom pizza. As soon as I picked it up I knew it was not normal. About half the cheese and ingre...

Read full review

M
Mike Kehoe
Reviews 1
2020-06-15 18:28

I don't get how this place gets such high reviews....

I don't get how this place gets such high reviews... the crust is like cardboard and there is absolutely nothing special about this pizza... my sister will get it because it is so close to her house but she has to order the "extra thin" crust to like it (makes it tolerable for me). So... I'm giving ...

Read full review

J
James Pullen
Reviews 1
2020-06-14 05:06

The Best Pizza in the Northwest Suburbs, hands dow...

The Best Pizza in the Northwest Suburbs, hands down!!. I am orginally from the south side and most pizza places are decent, if not great down there. This is not the case when it comes to the northwest suburbs. But then I found Sal's. I can not say enough about the perfection this place bring to maki...

Read full review

J
jennifer wickersty
Reviews 1
2020-06-05 21:32

I ordered the garbage pizza (has everything on it)...

I ordered the garbage pizza (has everything on it) about a month ago. I like it so much I have had it twice since. My kids like the peporoni pizza. The crust is thin and crispy and the sauce has a good flavor. When we are not in the mood for Lou Malnatis deep dish we will eat Sals!

Read full review

A
Ahah Brbr
Reviews 1
2020-06-03 12:52

We ordered a small deep dish pizza with onions. Wh...

We ordered a small deep dish pizza with onions. When we ate the pizza, the tomato sauce tasted like it came out of a can. Not much cheese on top, and a lot of dough. Very disappointed, as we paid around $23.00 for a pizza that I would rate a "zero!" Don't waste your time with Sal's. Even Pizza Hut ...

Read full review

I
Independent Mind
Reviews 1
2020-05-21 12:32

This used to be a decent place for pizza until the...

This used to be a decent place for pizza until they decided to go totally maskless during the COVID pandemic . None of the cooks, cashiers or anyone had masks and were within inches of food and others .One sneeze and the pizza may as well be called Covid contagion. There are so many other pizza plac...

Read full review

T
Trisha Carlson
Reviews 1
2020-05-20 19:48

I grew up with a joint just like this, it was my f...

I grew up with a joint just like this, it was my family's favorite pizza place for 30+ years, I ended up getting my first job there which lasted for 5 years. We were known for having not only great pizza but having great pizza consistently. We had so many customers who we knew so well that all we n...

Read full review

P
Preston Beres
Reviews 1
2020-05-19 18:27

I can understand how this place gets such high rev...

I can understand how this place gets such high reviews! The crust especially is fantastic! Everything about the pizza is special when compared to other companies. I always get it because how close it is and it doesn't even matter the different types of pizza because they are all awesome and tolera...

Read full review

S
Scott Gallagher
Reviews 1
2020-05-16 04:11

I had a friend who is a BIG connoisseur of fine fa...

I had a friend who is a BIG connoisseur of fine fast food recommend this place. Bottom line, Sal focuses on quality ingredients. Period. High quality Chicago style pizza from a true italian. As a single dude in my 30's, you can't get a better pizza in the area. Hands down.

Read full review

S
Sylvia Sikkelerus
Reviews 1
2020-05-11 20:23

I ve lived in the area for about two years and had...

I ve lived in the area for about two years and hadn't found anyplace that had decent ribs. Since I m stuck in the house, I thought I d start reading reviews and read nothing but good things about Sal s, soooo I thought I d give them a try! Mmmmmmm I m so glad I did. Ordered enough for the family, a...

Read full review

M
Michael Thompson
Reviews 1
2020-05-09 21:40

This site is my favorite site. Of all restaurants...

This site is my favorite site. Of all restaurants I know I like it most. I never miss an opportunity to go to visit this place. when I feel like having a special lunch, this is the place that comes straight to my head. superb and all sorts of food and a large menu.helpful staff, and great atmosph...

Read full review

S
Sven Blomsterberg
Reviews 1
2020-05-01 21:55

We have lived in the area for over 8 years and hav...

We have lived in the area for over 8 years and have always seen this place but never went before. Tonight I was looking up a new pizza place and it came up across multiple apps with amazing reviews. Now I know why lol. The food is incredible! The best pizza I ve had outside of the loop! Pricey ...

Read full review

A
Aaron Priebe
Reviews 1
2020-04-02 08:15

Sal's Pizza does an amazing job. Think high qualit...

Sal's Pizza does an amazing job. Think high quality Rosatis. My go-to at Sal's is double cheese, double beef (italian), extra sauce. It's greasy and heavy. All my major life events in this area are based around Sal's. Moving, kitchen remodel, birthdays; Sal's is the go-to. Come hungry. xD

Read full review

View all reviews on Trustburn