I really thought it wouldn't live up to the hype b...

I really thought it wouldn't live up to the hype but it was truly the best slice of apple pie I've had in NYC, actually maybe ever. I got the salted caramel apple and it was fantastic. I guess the only downside was that it was a little too small of a slice. Save your money and buy the whole dang pie! The atmosphere is coffee shop esque, people posted up on laptops and reading books and such. Quiet and relaxed. I've tried Martha's, Petee's, Blue Stove, and others, and this apple pie beats all of them. Those others were delicious, don't get me wrong, but this one won!