The pie here is amazing! I stumbled upon this plac...

The pie here is amazing! I stumbled upon this place when researching pies to take to a Thanksgiving dinner. The pie shop is cute, but a little out of the way, so I usually pick up slices from other places like the Brooklyn Library or the McNally Jackson bookstore in SoHo. But if you do make it out to the store you'll find a greater variety there, including some interesting savory options. The Salted Caramel Apple is a staple, but the Lemon is amazingly refreshing in the summer.